Medical Scientist Training Program, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA.
Early Interv Psychiatry. 2012 Nov;6(4):368-79. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-7893.2012.00383.x. Epub 2012 Jul 8.
To conduct a systematic review of the methods and performance characteristics of models developed for predicting the onset of psychosis.
We performed a comprehensive literature search restricted to English articles and identified using PubMed, Medline and PsychINFO, as well as the reference lists of published studies and reviews. Inclusion criteria included the selection of more than one variable to predict psychosis or schizophrenia onset, and selection of individuals at familial risk or clinical high risk. Eighteen studies met these criteria, and we compared these studies based on the subjects selected, predictor variables used and the choice of statistical or machine learning methods.
Quality of life and life functioning as well as structural brain imaging emerged as the most promising predictors of psychosis onset, particularly when they were coupled with appropriate dimensionality reduction methods and predictive model algorithms like the support vector machine (SVM). Balanced accuracy ranged from 100% to 78% in four studies using the SVM, and 67% to 81% in 14 studies using general linear models.
Performance of the predictive models improves with quality of life measures, life functioning measures, structural brain imaging data, as well as with the use of methods like SVM. Despite these advances, the overall performance of psychosis predictive models is still modest. In the future, performance can potentially be improved by including genetic variant and new functional imaging data in addition to the predictors that are used currently.
系统综述用于预测精神病发作的模型的方法和性能特征。
我们进行了全面的文献检索,仅限于英文文章,并通过 PubMed、Medline 和 PsychINFO 以及已发表研究和综述的参考文献进行了识别。纳入标准包括选择多个变量来预测精神病或精神分裂症发作,以及选择家族风险或临床高风险个体。有 18 项研究符合这些标准,我们根据所选的研究对象、使用的预测变量以及统计或机器学习方法的选择对这些研究进行了比较。
生活质量和生活功能以及结构脑成像成为精神病发作最有前途的预测指标,特别是当它们与适当的降维方法和预测模型算法(如支持向量机 (SVM))结合使用时。四项使用 SVM 的研究中平衡准确性为 100%至 78%,十四项使用广义线性模型的研究中平衡准确性为 67%至 81%。
使用 SVM 等方法可提高预测模型的性能,包括生活质量指标、生活功能指标、结构脑成像数据。尽管取得了这些进展,但精神病预测模型的整体性能仍然不高。在未来,通过在当前使用的预测因子之外纳入遗传变异和新的功能成像数据,性能有可能得到提高。