Kosslyn Stephen M, Kievit Rogier A, Russell Alexandra G, Shephard Jennifer M
Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University Stanford, CA USA.
Front Psychol. 2012 Jul 17;3:230. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2012.00230. eCollection 2012.
Electronic slideshow presentations are often faulted anecdotally, but little empirical work has documented their faults. In Study 1 we found that eight psychological principles are often violated in PowerPoint(®) slideshows, and are violated to similar extents across different fields - for example, academic research slideshows generally were no better or worse than business slideshows. In Study 2 we found that respondents reported having noticed, and having been annoyed by, specific problems in presentations arising from violations of particular psychological principles. Finally, in Study 3 we showed that observers are not highly accurate in recognizing when particular slides violated a specific psychological rule. Furthermore, even when they correctly identified the violation, they often could not explain the nature of the problem. In sum, the psychological foundations for effective slideshow presentation design are neither obvious nor necessarily intuitive, and presentation designers in all fields, from education to business to government, could benefit from explicit instruction in relevant aspects of psychology.
电子幻灯片演示常常受到坊间诟病,但鲜有实证研究记录其缺陷。在研究1中,我们发现PowerPoint(®)幻灯片演示常常违反八条心理学原理,且在不同领域的违反程度相似——例如,学术研究幻灯片演示总体上并不比商务幻灯片演示好或差。在研究2中,我们发现受访者表示注意到了因违反特定心理学原理而在演示中出现的具体问题,并为此感到恼火。最后,在研究3中,我们表明观察者在识别特定幻灯片何时违反特定心理学规则时并不十分准确。此外,即使他们正确识别出了违规行为,也往往无法解释问题的本质。总之,有效幻灯片演示设计的心理学基础既不明显也不一定直观,从教育到商业再到政府的所有领域的演示设计师都可以从心理学相关方面的明确指导中受益。