Department of Biomedical Informatics, 36 Eagle Row, Room 572 PAIS, Emory University Hospital, Atlanta, GA 30322, USA.
Radiology. 2013 May;267(2):560-9. doi: 10.1148/radiol.13120118. Epub 2013 Feb 7.
To conduct a comprehensive analysis of radiologist-made assessments of glioblastoma (GBM) tumor size and composition by using a community-developed controlled terminology of magnetic resonance (MR) imaging visual features as they relate to genetic alterations, gene expression class, and patient survival.
Because all study patients had been previously deidentified by the Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA), a publicly available data set that contains no linkage to patient identifiers and that is HIPAA compliant, no institutional review board approval was required. Presurgical MR images of 75 patients with GBM with genetic data in the TCGA portal were rated by three neuroradiologists for size, location, and tumor morphology by using a standardized feature set. Interrater agreements were analyzed by using the Krippendorff α statistic and intraclass correlation coefficient. Associations between survival, tumor size, and morphology were determined by using multivariate Cox regression models; associations between imaging features and genomics were studied by using the Fisher exact test.
Interrater analysis showed significant agreement in terms of contrast material enhancement, nonenhancement, necrosis, edema, and size variables. Contrast-enhanced tumor volume and longest axis length of tumor were strongly associated with poor survival (respectively, hazard ratio: 8.84, P = .0253, and hazard ratio: 1.02, P = .00973), even after adjusting for Karnofsky performance score (P = .0208). Proneural class GBM had significantly lower levels of contrast enhancement (P = .02) than other subtypes, while mesenchymal GBM showed lower levels of nonenhanced tumor (P < .01).
This analysis demonstrates a method for consistent image feature annotation capable of reproducibly characterizing brain tumors; this study shows that radiologists' estimations of macroscopic imaging features can be combined with genetic alterations and gene expression subtypes to provide deeper insight to the underlying biologic properties of GBM subsets.
通过使用社区开发的磁共振(MR)成像视觉特征控制术语,对胶质母细胞瘤(GBM)肿瘤大小和成分进行综合分析,这些术语与遗传改变、基因表达类型和患者生存相关。
由于所有研究患者均已通过癌症基因组图谱(TCGA)进行了预先去识别,TCGA 是一个公开可用的数据集,其中不包含与患者标识符的链接,并且符合 HIPAA 规定,因此不需要机构审查委员会的批准。通过使用标准化特征集,对 TCGA 门户中具有遗传数据的 75 例 GBM 患者的术前 MR 图像进行了三位神经放射学家的大小、位置和肿瘤形态的评分。通过 Krippendorff α 统计量和组内相关系数分析了组间一致性。通过多变量 Cox 回归模型确定生存、肿瘤大小和形态之间的关联;通过 Fisher 精确检验研究影像学特征与基因组学之间的关联。
组间分析显示,在对比增强、非增强、坏死、水肿和大小变量方面具有显著的一致性。增强肿瘤体积和肿瘤最长轴长度与较差的生存显著相关(分别为危险比:8.84,P =.0253 和危险比:1.02,P =.00973),即使在调整卡诺夫斯基表现评分后(P =.0208)也是如此。原神经型 GBM 的对比增强水平明显低于其他亚型(P =.02),而间充质 GBM 的非增强肿瘤水平较低(P <.01)。
本分析证明了一种能够可靠地描述脑肿瘤的一致图像特征标注方法;本研究表明,放射科医生对宏观影像学特征的评估可以与遗传改变和基因表达亚型相结合,为 GBM 亚群的潜在生物学特性提供更深入的了解。