Jose Mini M, Dufrene Claudine
University of Texas Medical Branch School of Nursing, 301 University Blvd, Galveston, TX 77555, United States.
Nurse Educ Today. 2014 Apr;34(4):543-51. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2013.07.021. Epub 2013 Aug 12.
This integrative review of literature was conducted to determine (1) what are the suitable disaster preparedness competencies for undergraduate nursing curriculum? and (2) what are the suitable methods of instruction to deliver disaster preparedness content?
A literature search was conducted on three major electronic databases: Ovid MEDLINE, PubMed and the Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) using the keywords; Disaster Preparedness, Disaster and nursing education; disaster response and nursing education. Limiters used were published within the last 10 years and in nursing field. Out of the 190 articles retrieved, eight were research articles that met the inclusion criteria. These articles were carefully reviewed and the results are summarized in two sections to answer the research questions.
There was no uniformity of intended competencies among the studies, though all studies used resources from reputed national and international organizations. All the studies reviewed adhered to a systematic approach in delivering content and used eclectic methods including multiple technologies to enhance the educational outcomes. Most of the studies had incorporated simulation in different ways involving low to high fidelity simulators, virtual simulation and live actors. Content and length of the programs were greatly varied but stayed focused on the general principles of disaster management and appropriate for the level of the students within the programs.
More rigorous research is needed in this area since all published articles had deficiencies in the methodologies, especially in data collection and analysis. Disaster preparedness education was found to be a suitable activity for interprofessional education.
进行本次文献综合回顾,以确定(1)本科护理课程中合适的备灾能力有哪些?以及(2)传授备灾内容的合适教学方法有哪些?
在三个主要电子数据库(Ovid MEDLINE、PubMed和护理及相关健康文献累积索引(CINAHL))上进行文献检索,使用关键词:备灾、灾难与护理教育;灾难应对与护理教育。使用的限制条件为过去10年内发表且属于护理领域。在检索到的190篇文章中,有8篇是符合纳入标准的研究文章。对这些文章进行了仔细回顾,并将结果归纳为两个部分以回答研究问题。
尽管所有研究都使用了知名国家和国际组织的资源,但各研究在预期能力方面并无统一标准。所有被回顾的研究在传授内容时都遵循系统方法,并使用了包括多种技术在内的折衷方法来提高教育效果。大多数研究都以不同方式纳入了模拟,涉及从低保真模拟器到高保真模拟器、虚拟模拟和真人演员。课程的内容和时长差异很大,但都聚焦于灾害管理的一般原则,且适合课程中学生的水平。
由于所有已发表文章在方法上都存在缺陷,尤其是在数据收集和分析方面,因此该领域需要更严谨的研究。备灾教育被认为是跨专业教育的合适活动。