Universidade de São Paulo, Faculdade de Saúde Pública, São PauloSPBrazil.
Rev Saude Publica. 2013 Apr;47(2):316-25. doi: 10.1590/S0034-8910.2013047003798.
To evaluate the effects of using post-stratification weight to correct the bias due to low coverage of households with telephones.
A Comparison was made of results collected by the Household Survey with those of the VIGITEL (Telephone Survey to Monitor Risk and Protective Factors for Chronic Diseases) in Rio Branco, Northern Brazil, in 2007 whose coverage was 40% of landline phones. The potential bias in the VIGITEL survey was expressed by the difference between the rates of prevalence of the VIGITEL and Household Survey, calculated as the square root mean square error (MSE) as a measure of the accuracy of the estimate.
The weighting procedure of VIGITEL corrected potential bias in the prevalence of consumption of fruit and vegetables, meat with visible fat, smoking, bad self-assessment of health status and morbidity of cholesterol or triglycerides. In the prevalence of physical activity in leisure time and morbidity of asthma, bronchial asthma, chronic bronchitis or emphysema, the procedure adopted by VIGITEL did not reduce the potential bias.
in order to construct post-stratification weights which minimize the potential bias in estimates of the variables due to low coverage of households with landlines, it becomes necessary to use alternative methods of weighting and strategies of selecting external variables.
评估使用事后分层权重来纠正因电话覆盖不足导致的家庭偏差的效果。
比较了 2007 年在巴西北里奥格兰德州里奥布兰科进行的家庭调查和 VIGITEL(监测慢性病风险和保护因素的电话调查)的结果,后者的电话覆盖范围仅为固定电话的 40%。VIGITEL 调查的潜在偏差通过 VIGITEL 和家庭调查的患病率之间的差异来表示,该差异通过均方根误差(MSE)的平方根来衡量,作为估计准确性的指标。
VIGITEL 的加权程序纠正了水果和蔬菜消费、带可见脂肪的肉类、吸烟、自我健康状况评估不佳以及胆固醇或甘油三酯发病率等变量的患病率方面的潜在偏差。在休闲时间的体力活动和哮喘、支气管哮喘、慢性支气管炎或肺气肿发病率的患病率方面,VIGITEL 采用的程序并没有降低潜在偏差。
为了构建事后分层权重,以最小化因固定电话家庭覆盖率低而导致的变量估计中的潜在偏差,有必要使用替代的加权方法和外部变量选择策略。