Public Health and Practice-Changing Research, Centre de recherche du CHU de Québec, Québec, Canada.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2014 May-Jun;21(3):535-41. doi: 10.1136/amiajnl-2013-002203. Epub 2013 Oct 15.
We conducted a systematic review identifying users groups' perceptions of barriers and facilitators to implementing electronic prescription (e-prescribing) in primary care.
We included studies following these criteria: presence of an empirical design, focus on the users' experience of e-prescribing implementation, conducted in primary care, and providing data on barriers and facilitators to e-prescribing implementation. We used the Donabedian logical model of healthcare quality (adapted by Barber et al) to analyze our findings.
We found 34 publications (related to 28 individual studies) eligible to be included in this review. These studies identified a total of 594 elements as barriers or facilitators to e-prescribing implementation. Most user groups perceived that e-prescribing was facilitated by design and technical concerns, interoperability, content appropriate for the users, attitude towards e-prescribing, productivity, and available resources.
This review highlights the importance of technical and organizational support for the successful implementation of e-prescribing systems. It also shows that the same factor can be seen as a barrier or a facilitator depending on the project's own circumstances. Moreover, a factor can change in nature, from a barrier to a facilitator and vice versa, in the process of e-prescribing implementation.
This review summarizes current knowledge on factors related to e-prescribing implementation in primary care that could support decision makers in their design of effective implementation strategies. Finally, future studies should emphasize on the perceptions of other user groups, such as pharmacists, managers, vendors, and patients, who remain neglected in the literature.
我们进行了一项系统评价,以确定用户群体对在初级保健中实施电子处方(e-prescribing)的障碍和促进因素的看法。
我们纳入了符合以下标准的研究:存在实证设计、关注用户对电子处方实施的体验、在初级保健中进行、并提供关于电子处方实施障碍和促进因素的数据。我们使用 Donabedian 医疗保健质量逻辑模型(由 Barber 等人改编)来分析我们的发现。
我们发现 34 篇出版物(涉及 28 项单独的研究)符合纳入本综述的标准。这些研究共确定了 594 个要素作为电子处方实施的障碍或促进因素。大多数用户群体认为,设计和技术问题、互操作性、适合用户的内容、对电子处方的态度、生产力和可用资源促进了电子处方的实施。
本综述强调了技术和组织支持对电子处方系统成功实施的重要性。它还表明,同一因素可能被视为障碍或促进因素,具体取决于项目自身的情况。此外,在电子处方实施过程中,一个因素的性质可能会从障碍转变为促进因素,反之亦然。
本综述总结了当前关于初级保健中与电子处方实施相关的因素的知识,这些知识可以为决策者设计有效的实施策略提供支持。最后,未来的研究应强调药剂师、管理人员、供应商和患者等其他用户群体的看法,这些群体在文献中被忽视了。