Oostvogels A J J M, De Wit G A, Jahn B, Cassini A, Colzani E, De Waure C, Kretzschmar M E E, Siebert U, Mühlberger N, Mangen M-J J
University Medical Centre Utrecht (UMCU),Utrecht,The Netherlands.
Institute of Public Health, Medical Decision Making and Health Technology Assessment,Department of Public Health and Health Technology Assessment,UMIT - University for Health Sciences,Medical Informatics and Technology,Hall i.T.,Austria.
Epidemiol Infect. 2015 Jul;143(9):1791-802. doi: 10.1017/S0950268814001940. Epub 2014 Dec 12.
A systematic literature review was performed on full economic evaluations of infectious disease interventions using disability-adjusted life years (DALY) as outcome measure. The search was limited to the period between 1994 and September 2011 and conducted in Medline, SciSearch and EMBASE databases. We included 154 studies, mostly targeting HIV/AIDS and malaria with most conducted for African countries (40%) and <10% in high-income countries. Third-payer perspective was applied in 29% of the studies, 25% used the societal perspective and 12% used both. Only 16% of the studies took indirect effects (i.e. herd immunity) of interventions into account. Intervention, direct healthcare and indirect non-healthcare costs were taken into account in respectively 100%, 81% and 36% of the studies. The majority of the studies followed the Global Burden of Disease method for DALY estimations, but most studies deviated from WHO cost-effectiveness guidelines. Better adherence to freely accessible guidelines will improve generalizability between full economic evaluations.
我们对以伤残调整生命年(DALY)作为结果指标的传染病干预措施的全面经济评估进行了系统的文献综述。检索范围限定在1994年至2011年9月期间,并在Medline、SciSearch和EMBASE数据库中进行。我们纳入了154项研究,这些研究大多针对艾滋病毒/艾滋病和疟疾,其中大部分是针对非洲国家开展的(40%),在高收入国家开展的不到10%。29%的研究采用第三方支付者视角,25%采用社会视角,12%同时采用这两种视角。只有16%的研究考虑了干预措施的间接影响(即群体免疫)。分别有100%、81%和36%的研究考虑了干预措施、直接医疗保健和间接非医疗保健成本。大多数研究遵循全球疾病负担方法来估算DALY,但大多数研究偏离了世卫组织的成本效益指南。更好地遵循可免费获取的指南将提高全面经济评估之间的可推广性。