Santa Maria Diane, Markham Christine, Bluethmann Shirley, Mullen Patricia Dolan
Department of Nursing Systems, University of Texas School of Nursing, Houston.
Perspect Sex Reprod Health. 2015 Mar;47(1):37-50. doi: 10.1363/47e2415. Epub 2015 Jan 30.
Parent-based adolescent sexual health interventions aim to reduce sexual risk behaviors by bolstering parental protective behaviors. Few studies of theory use, methods, applications, delivery and outcomes of parent-based interventions have been conducted.
A systematic search of databases for the period 1998-2013 identified 28 published trials of U.S. parent-based interventions to examine theory use, setting, reach, delivery mode, dose and effects on parent-child communication. Established coding schemes were used to assess use of theory and describe methods employed to achieve behavioral change; intervention effects were explored in meta-analyses.
Most interventions were conducted with minority parents in group sessions or via self-paced activities; interventions averaged seven hours, and most used theory extensively. Meta-analyses found improvements in sexual health communication: Analysis of 11 controlled trials indicated a medium effect on increasing communication (Cohen's d, 0.5), and analysis of nine trials found a large effect on increasing parental comfort with communication (0.7); effects were positive regardless of delivery mode or intervention dose. Intervention participants were 68% more likely than controls to report increased communication and 75% more likely to report increased comfort.
These findings point to gaps in the range of programs examined in published trials-for example, interventions for parents of sexual minority youth, programs for custodial grandparents and faith-based services. Yet they provide support for the effectiveness of parent-based interventions in improving communication. Innovative delivery approaches could extend programs' reach, and further research on sexual health outcomes would facilitate the meta-analysis of intervention effectiveness in improving adolescent sexual health behaviors.
基于父母的青少年性健康干预旨在通过加强父母的保护行为来减少性风险行为。针对基于父母的干预措施的理论应用、方法、实施、交付方式及效果的研究较少。
对1998年至2013年期间的数据库进行系统检索,确定了28项已发表的针对美国父母的干预试验,以研究理论应用、环境、覆盖面、交付模式、剂量以及对亲子沟通的影响。使用既定的编码方案来评估理论的应用,并描述为实现行为改变所采用的方法;在荟萃分析中探讨干预效果。
大多数干预是与少数族裔父母在小组会议中或通过自主节奏的活动进行的;干预平均时长为7小时,且大多数广泛应用了理论。荟萃分析发现性健康沟通有所改善:对11项对照试验的分析表明,对增加沟通有中等效果(科恩d值为0.5),对9项试验的分析发现,对提高父母沟通舒适度有较大效果(0.7);无论交付模式或干预剂量如何,效果均为正向。干预参与者报告沟通增加的可能性比对照组高68%,报告舒适度增加的可能性高75%。
这些发现指出了已发表试验中所研究项目范围的差距——例如,针对性少数青年父母的干预、针对监护祖父母的项目以及基于信仰的服务。然而,它们为基于父母的干预在改善沟通方面的有效性提供了支持。创新的交付方式可以扩大项目的覆盖面,对性健康结果的进一步研究将有助于对干预改善青少年性健康行为有效性的荟萃分析。