Simner Julia, Carmichael Duncan A
a School of Psychology, Pevensey Building , University of Sussex , Falmer , UK.
Cogn Neurosci. 2015;6(2-3):68-76. doi: 10.1080/17588928.2015.1019441. Epub 2015 Mar 9.
Synaesthesia is a familial condition that gives rise to unusual secondary percepts. We present a large-scale prevalence study which informs our ideas on whether the condition is more prevalent in men or women. A number of studies over the last 20 years have suggested the condition is found more commonly in women, with up to six times more female synaesthetes than male. Other studies attributed this female bias to merely a recruitment confound: women synaesthetes may be more likely to self-refer for study. We offer two pieces of evidence that there is no extreme female bias in synaesthesia: first we re-analyse previous reports of very large female biases to show again that they likely arose from self-referral or other methodological issues. Second, we present the largest published prevalence study to date on grapheme→colour synaesthesia in which our prevalence (1.39% of the population) replicates our earlier estimates (and in which we demonstrate no strong female bias even with sufficient power to detect such a difference.
联觉是一种家族性病症,会引发异常的次级感知。我们开展了一项大规模患病率研究,以了解这种病症在男性和女性中是否更为普遍。过去20年的多项研究表明,这种病症在女性中更为常见,女性联觉者的数量是男性的六倍之多。其他研究将这种女性偏向仅仅归因于招募混淆:女性联觉者可能更倾向于主动参与研究。我们提供了两条证据,证明联觉不存在极端的女性偏向:首先,我们重新分析了之前关于女性存在极大偏向的报告,再次表明这些偏向可能源于自我推荐或其他方法学问题。其次,我们呈现了迄今为止关于字形→颜色联觉的最大规模已发表患病率研究,其中我们的患病率(占人口的1.39%)与我们早期的估计相符(并且我们证明,即使有足够的能力检测出这种差异,也不存在强烈的女性偏向)。