Lee Sylvia E, Kibby Michelle Y, Cohen Morris J, Stanford Lisa, Park Yong, Strickland Suzanne
Department of Psychology and Center for Integrated Research in Cognitive & Neural Sciences Southern Illinois University, LSII, Room 281,Carbondale, IL 62901.
Department of Neurology, Medical College of Georgia at Georgia Regents University, Children's Medical Center, 1446 Harper Street, Augusta, GA 30912.
Child Neuropsychol. 2016;22(8):979-1000. doi: 10.1080/09297049.2015.1060955. Epub 2015 Jul 8.
Prior research has shown that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and epilepsy are frequently comorbid and that both disorders are associated with various attention and memory problems. Nonetheless, limited research has been conducted comparing the two disorders in one sample to determine unique versus shared deficits. Hence, we investigated differences in working memory (WM) and short-term and delayed recall between children with ADHD, focal epilepsy of mixed foci, comorbid ADHD/epilepsy and controls. Participants were compared on the Core subtests and the Picture Locations subtest of the Children's Memory Scale (CMS). Results indicated that children with ADHD displayed intact verbal WM and long-term memory (LTM), as well as intact performance on most aspects of short-term memory (STM). They performed worse than controls on Numbers Forward and Picture Locations, suggesting problems with focused attention and simple span for visual-spatial material. Conversely, children with epilepsy displayed poor focused attention and STM regardless of the modality assessed, which affected encoding into LTM. The only loss over time was found for passages (Stories). WM was intact. Children with comorbid ADHD/epilepsy displayed focused attention and STM/LTM problems consistent with both disorders, having the lowest scores across the four groups. Hence, focused attention and visual-spatial span appear to be affected in both disorders, whereas additional STM/encoding problems are specific to epilepsy. Children with comorbid ADHD/epilepsy have deficits consistent with both disorders, with slight additive effects. This study suggests that attention and memory testing should be a regular part of the evaluation of children with epilepsy and ADHD.
先前的研究表明,注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)和癫痫常常并发,且这两种疾病都与各种注意力和记忆问题有关。尽管如此,在同一个样本中比较这两种疾病以确定独特缺陷与共同缺陷的研究却很有限。因此,我们调查了患有ADHD、混合病灶局灶性癫痫、ADHD/癫痫共病的儿童与对照组儿童在工作记忆(WM)、短期和延迟回忆方面的差异。对参与者进行了儿童记忆量表(CMS)的核心子测试和图片位置子测试。结果表明,患有ADHD的儿童在言语WM和长期记忆(LTM)方面表现正常,在短期记忆(STM)的大多数方面表现也正常。他们在顺背数字和图片位置测试中的表现比对照组差,这表明在集中注意力和视觉空间材料的简单广度方面存在问题。相反,癫痫患儿无论评估的是哪种模式,其集中注意力和STM都较差,这影响了向LTM的编码。随着时间的推移,仅在段落(故事)方面发现了遗忘。WM是完整的。患有ADHD/癫痫共病的儿童表现出与两种疾病一致的集中注意力和STM/LTM问题,在四组中得分最低。因此,两种疾病似乎都影响集中注意力和视觉空间广度,而额外的STM/编码问题则是癫痫特有的。患有ADHD/癫痫共病的儿童存在与两种疾病一致的缺陷,且有轻微的累加效应。这项研究表明,注意力和记忆测试应该成为癫痫和ADHD患儿评估的常规部分。