Chang Ellen T, Adami Hans-Olov, Boffetta Paolo, Wedner H James, Mandel Jack S
a Health Sciences Practice, Exponent, Inc , Menlo Park , CA , USA ;
b Division of Epidemiology, Department of Health Research and Policy , Stanford University School of Medicine , Stanford , CA , USA ;
Crit Rev Toxicol. 2016;46(4):279-331. doi: 10.3109/10408444.2015.1122573. Epub 2016 Jan 13.
Whether perfluorooctanoate (PFOA) and perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS), two widely used and biopersistent synthetic chemicals, are immunotoxic in humans is unclear. Accordingly, this article systematically and critically reviews the epidemiologic evidence on the association between exposure to PFOA and PFOS and various immune-related health conditions in humans. Twenty-four epidemiologic studies have reported associations of PFOA and/or PFOS with immune-related health conditions, including ten studies of immune biomarker levels or gene expression patterns, ten studies of atopic or allergic disorders, five studies of infectious diseases, four studies of vaccine responses, and five studies of chronic inflammatory or autoimmune conditions (with several studies evaluating multiple endpoints). Asthma, the most commonly studied condition, was evaluated in seven studies. With few, often methodologically limited studies of any particular health condition, generally inconsistent results, and an inability to exclude confounding, bias, or chance as an explanation for observed associations, the available epidemiologic evidence is insufficient to reach a conclusion about a causal relationship between exposure to PFOA and PFOS and any immune-related health condition in humans. When interpreting such studies, an immunodeficiency should not be presumed to exist when there is no evidence of a clinical abnormality. Large, prospective studies with repeated exposure assessment in independent populations are needed to confirm some suggestive associations with certain endpoints.
两种广泛使用且具有生物持久性的合成化学物质全氟辛酸(PFOA)和全氟辛烷磺酸(PFOS)对人体是否具有免疫毒性尚不清楚。因此,本文系统且批判性地综述了关于接触PFOA和PFOS与人类各种免疫相关健康状况之间关联的流行病学证据。24项流行病学研究报告了PFOA和/或PFOS与免疫相关健康状况的关联,其中包括10项关于免疫生物标志物水平或基因表达模式的研究、10项关于特应性或过敏性疾病的研究、5项关于传染病的研究、4项关于疫苗反应的研究以及5项关于慢性炎症或自身免疫性疾病的研究(有几项研究评估了多个终点)。哮喘是研究最多的疾病,有7项研究对其进行了评估。由于针对任何特定健康状况的研究很少,且在方法上往往存在局限性,结果普遍不一致,并且无法排除混杂因素、偏倚或偶然性作为观察到的关联的解释,因此现有的流行病学证据不足以就接触PFOA和PFOS与人类任何免疫相关健康状况之间的因果关系得出结论。在解释此类研究时,若无临床异常证据,不应假定存在免疫缺陷。需要在独立人群中进行重复暴露评估的大型前瞻性研究,以证实与某些终点的一些提示性关联。