Bradbury Angela, Patrick-Miller Linda, Harris Diana, Stevens Evelyn, Egleston Brian, Smith Kyle, Mueller Rebecca, Brandt Amanda, Stopfer Jill, Rauch Shea, Forman Andrea, Kim Rebecca, Fetzer Dominique, Fleisher Linda, Daly Mary, Domchek Susan
Division of Hematology-Oncology, Department of Medicine, The University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2016 Feb 1;18(2):e23. doi: 10.2196/jmir.4564.
Videoconferencing has been used to expand medical services to low-access populations and could increase access to genetic services at community sites where in-person visits with genetic providers are not available.
To evaluate the feasibility of, patient feedback of, and cognitive and affective responses to remote two-way videoconferencing (RVC) telegenetic services at multiple sociodemographically diverse community practices without access to genetic providers.
Patients at 3 community sites in 2 US states outside the host center completed RVC pretest (visit 1, V1) and post-test (visit 2, V2) genetic counseling for cancer susceptibility. Surveys evaluated patient experiences, knowledge, satisfaction with telegenetic and cancer genetics services, anxiety, depression, and cancer worry.
A total of 82 out of 100 (82.0%) approached patients consented to RVC services. A total of 61 out of 82 patients (74%) completed pretest counseling and 41 out of 61 (67%) proceeded with testing and post-test counseling. A total of 4 out of 41 (10%) mutation carriers were identified: BRCA2, MSH2, and PMS2. Patients reported many advantages (eg, lower travel burden and convenience) and few disadvantages to RVC telegenetic services. Most patients reported feeling comfortable with the video camera--post-V1: 52/57 (91%); post-V2: 39/41 (95%)--and that their privacy was respected--post-V1: 56/57 (98%); post-V2: 40/41 (98%); however, some reported concerns that RVC might increase the risk of a confidentiality breach of their health information--post-V1: 14/57 (25%); post-V2: 12/41 (29%). While the majority of patients reported having no trouble seeing or hearing the genetic counselor--post-V1: 47/57 (82%); post-V2: 39/41 (95%)--51 out of 98 (52%) patients reported technical difficulties. Nonetheless, all patients reported being satisfied with genetic services. Compared to baseline, knowledge increased significantly after pretest counseling (+1.11 mean score, P=.005); satisfaction with telegenetic (+1.74 mean score, P=.02) and genetic services (+2.22 mean score, P=.001) increased after post-test counseling. General anxiety and depression decreased after pretest (-0.97 mean anxiety score, P=.003; -0.37 mean depression score, P=.046) and post-test counseling (-1.13 mean anxiety score, P=.003; -0.75 mean depression score, P=.01); state anxiety and cancer-specific worry did not significantly increase.
Remote videoconferencing telegenetic services are feasible, identify genetic carriers in community practices, and are associated with high patient satisfaction and favorable cognitive and affective outcomes, suggesting an innovative delivery model for further study to improve access to genetic providers and services. Potential barriers to dissemination include technology costs, unclear billing and reimbursement, and state requirements for provider licensure.
视频会议已被用于将医疗服务扩展到难以获得服务的人群,并可增加在无法与基因服务提供者进行面对面就诊的社区场所获得基因服务的机会。
评估在多个社会人口统计学特征各异且无法获得基因服务提供者的社区医疗机构中,远程双向视频会议(RVC)远程基因服务的可行性、患者反馈以及认知和情感反应。
在美国东道主中心以外的2个州的3个社区场所的患者完成了针对癌症易感性的RVC预测试(第1次就诊,V1)和后测试(第2次就诊,V2)基因咨询。调查评估了患者的体验、知识、对远程基因和癌症基因服务的满意度、焦虑、抑郁和癌症担忧。
在100名被邀请的患者中,共有82名(82.0%)同意接受RVC服务。82名患者中有61名(74%)完成了预测试咨询,61名中有41名(67%)进行了检测和后测试咨询。在41名患者中总共识别出4名(10%)突变携带者:BRCA2、MSH2和PMS2。患者报告了RVC远程基因服务的许多优点(如旅行负担减轻和方便)和很少的缺点。大多数患者报告对摄像头感到舒适——V1后:52/57(91%);V2后:39/41(95%)——并且他们的隐私得到了尊重——V1后:56/57(98%);V2后:40/41(98%);然而,一些患者报告担心RVC可能会增加其健康信息保密泄露的风险——V1后:14/57(25%);V2后:12/41(29%)。虽然大多数患者报告在观看或聆听基因咨询师方面没有困难——V1后:47/57(82%);V2后:39/41(95%)——但98名患者中有51名(52%)报告存在技术困难。尽管如此,所有患者均报告对基因服务感到满意。与基线相比,预测试咨询后知识显著增加(平均得分+1.11,P = 0.005);后测试咨询后对远程基因(平均得分+1.74,P = 0.02)和基因服务(平均得分+2.22,P = 0.001)的满意度增加。预测试(平均焦虑得分-0.97,P = 0.003;平均抑郁得分-0.37,P = 0.046)和后测试咨询(平均焦虑得分-1.13,P = 0.003;平均抑郁得分-0.75,P = 0.01)后,一般焦虑和抑郁有所下降;状态焦虑和癌症特异性担忧没有显著增加。
远程视频会议远程基因服务是可行的,能在社区医疗机构中识别基因携带者,且与患者的高满意度以及良好的认知和情感结果相关,提示这是一种可供进一步研究以改善获得基因服务提供者和服务机会的创新服务模式。传播的潜在障碍包括技术成本、计费和报销不明确以及州对提供者执照的要求。