Abu-Zidan Fikri M
Fikri M Abu-Zidan, Department of Surgery, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, UAE University, PO BOX 17666, Al-Ain, United Arab Emirates.
World J Crit Care Med. 2016 Feb 4;5(1):12-6. doi: 10.5492/wjccm.v5.i1.12.
We have tried in a recently published systematic review (World J of Surg 2014; 38: 322-329) to study the educational value of advanced trauma life support (ATLS) courses and whether they improve survival of multiple trauma patients. This Frontier article summarizes what we have learned and reflects on future perspectives in this important area. Our recently published systematic review has shown that ATLS training is very useful from an educational point view. It significantly increased knowledge, and improved practical skills and the critical decision making process in managing multiple trauma patients. These positive changes were evident in a wide range of learners including undergraduate medical students and postgraduate residents from different subspecialties. In contrast, clear evidence that ATLS training reduces trauma death is lacking. It is obvious that it is almost impossible to perform randomized controlled trials to study the effect of ATLS courses on trauma mortality. Studying factors predicting trauma mortality is a very complex issue. Accordingly, trauma mortality does not depend solely on ATLS training but on other important factors, like presence of well-developed trauma systems including advanced pre-hospital care. We think that the way to answer whether ATLS training improves survival is to perform large prospective cohort studies of high quality data and use advanced statistical modelling.
我们在最近发表的一项系统评价(《世界外科杂志》2014年;38: 322 - 329)中,尝试研究高级创伤生命支持(ATLS)课程的教育价值,以及它们是否能提高多发伤患者的生存率。这篇前沿文章总结了我们所学到的内容,并对这一重要领域的未来前景进行了思考。我们最近发表的系统评价表明,从教育角度来看,ATLS培训非常有用。它显著增加了知识,提高了实践技能以及处理多发伤患者时的关键决策过程。这些积极变化在广泛的学习者中都很明显,包括本科医学生和来自不同亚专业的研究生住院医师。相比之下,缺乏明确证据表明ATLS培训能降低创伤死亡率。显然,几乎不可能进行随机对照试验来研究ATLS课程对创伤死亡率的影响。研究预测创伤死亡率的因素是一个非常复杂的问题。因此创伤死亡率不仅仅取决于ATLS培训,还取决于其他重要因素,比如完善的创伤系统的存在,包括先进的院前护理。我们认为,回答ATLS培训是否能提高生存率的方法是进行高质量数据的大型前瞻性队列研究,并使用先进的统计模型。