Caeyenberghs Karen, Taymans Tom, Wilson Peter H, Vanderstraeten Guy, Hosseini Hadi, van Waelvelde Hilde
School of Psychology, Faculty of Health Sciences, Australian Catholic University, Australia.
School of Psychological Sciences, Monash Biomedical Imaging lab, Monash University, Australia.
Dev Sci. 2016 Jul;19(4):599-612. doi: 10.1111/desc.12424. Epub 2016 May 4.
Children with autism spectrum disorders (ASD) often exhibit motor clumsiness (Developmental Coordination Disorder, DCD), i.e. they struggle with everyday tasks that require motor coordination like dressing, self-care, and participating in sport and leisure activities. Previous studies in these neurodevelopmental disorders have demonstrated functional abnormalities and alterations of white matter microstructural integrity in specific brain regions. These findings suggest that the global organization of brain networks is affected in DCD and ASD and support the hypothesis of a 'dys-connectivity syndrome' from a network perspective. No studies have compared the structural covariance networks between ASD and DCD in order to look for the signature of DCD independent of comorbid autism. Here, we aimed to address the question of whether abnormal connectivity in DCD overlaps that seen in autism or comorbid DCD-autism. Using graph theoretical analysis, we investigated differences in global and regional topological properties of structural brain networks in 53 children: 8 ASD children with DCD (DCD+ASD), 15 ASD children without DCD (ASD), 11 with DCD only, and 19 typically developing (TD) children. We constructed separate structural correlation networks based on cortical thickness derived from Freesurfer. The children were assessed on the Movement-ABC and the Beery Test of Visual Motor Integration. Behavioral results demonstrated that the DCD group and DCD+ASD group scored on average poorer than the TD and ASD groups on various motor measures. Furthermore, although the brain networks of all groups exhibited small-world properties, the topological architecture of the networks was significantly altered in children with ASD compared with DCD and TD. ASD children showed increased normalized path length and higher values of clustering coefficient. Also, paralimbic regions exhibited nodal clustering coefficient alterations in singular disorders. These changes were disorder-specific, and included alterations in clustering coefficient in the isthmus of the right cingulate gyrus and the pars orbitalis of the right inferior frontal gyrus in ASD children, and DCD-related increases in the lateral orbitofrontal cortex. Children meeting criteria for both DCD and ASD exhibited topological changes that were more widespread from those seen in children with only DCD, i.e. children with DCD+ASD showed alterations of clustering coefficient in (para)limbic regions, primary areas, and association areas. The DCD+ASD group showed changes in clustering coefficient in the left association cortex relative to the ASD group. Finally, the DCD+ASD group shared ASD-specific abnormalities in the pars orbitalis of right inferior frontal gyrus, which was hypothesized to reflect atypical emotional-cognitive processing. Our results provide evidence that DCD and ASD are neurodevelopmental disorders with a low degree of overlap in abnormalities in connectivity. The co-occurrence of DCD+ASD was also associated with a distinct topological pattern, highlighting the unique neural signature of comorbid neurodevelopmental disorders.
患有自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)的儿童通常表现出运动笨拙(发育性协调障碍,DCD),即他们在诸如穿衣、自我护理以及参与体育和休闲活动等需要运动协调的日常任务中存在困难。先前针对这些神经发育障碍的研究已经证明了特定脑区白质微结构完整性的功能异常和改变。这些发现表明,脑网络的整体组织在DCD和ASD中受到影响,并从网络角度支持了“连接障碍综合征”的假说。尚无研究比较ASD和DCD之间的结构协方差网络,以寻找独立于共病自闭症的DCD特征。在此,我们旨在解决DCD中的异常连接是否与自闭症或共病DCD-自闭症中所见的异常连接重叠的问题。使用图论分析,我们研究了53名儿童脑结构网络的全局和区域拓扑特性差异:8名患有DCD的ASD儿童(DCD+ASD)、15名无DCD的ASD儿童(ASD)、11名仅患有DCD的儿童以及19名发育正常(TD)的儿童。我们基于Freesurfer得出的皮质厚度构建了单独的结构相关网络。对儿童进行了运动ABC测试和视觉运动整合的贝里测试。行为结果表明,在各种运动测量中,DCD组和DCD+ASD组的平均得分均低于TD组和ASD组。此外,尽管所有组的脑网络均表现出小世界特性,但与DCD和TD儿童相比,ASD儿童的网络拓扑结构发生了显著改变。ASD儿童表现出归一化路径长度增加和聚类系数值更高。此外,在单一疾病中,边缘旁区域表现出节点聚类系数改变。这些变化具有疾病特异性,包括ASD儿童右侧扣带回峡部和右侧额下回眶部的聚类系数改变,以及DCD相关的外侧眶额皮质增加。符合DCD和ASD标准的儿童表现出比仅患有DCD的儿童更广泛的拓扑变化,即患有DCD+ASD的儿童在(边缘旁)区域、初级区域和联合区域表现出聚类系数改变。相对于ASD组,DCD+ASD组在左侧联合皮质的聚类系数发生了变化。最后,DCD+ASD组在右侧额下回眶部存在ASD特异性异常,据推测这反映了非典型的情绪认知加工。我们的结果提供了证据,表明DCD和ASD是神经发育障碍,其连接异常的重叠程度较低。DCD+ASD的共病还与独特的拓扑模式相关,突出了共病神经发育障碍的独特神经特征。