Lee Kyung Won, Song Won O, Cho Mi Sook
Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Michigan State University, MI 48824, USA.
Department of Nutritional Science and Food Management, Ewha Womans University, 52, Ewhayeodae-gil, Sodaemun-gu, Seoul 03760, Korea.
Nutr Res Pract. 2016 Jun;10(3):294-304. doi: 10.4162/nrp.2016.10.3.294. Epub 2015 Dec 18.
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Eating out has been reported to have negative effects on nutritional status. However, eating out can include meals prepared at home and eaten outside. Conversely, meals eaten at home can be brought from outside, as take-out and home deliveries have become common in Korea. Thus, we tested whether or not meal preparation location influences daily diet quality.
SUBJECTS/METHODS: From the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES) 2007-2009, 4,915 Korean adults (20-64 years) were classified into two groups: home-made meal group (HMG), who ate ≥ 2 meals per day prepared at home (n = 4,146), and non-home-made meal group (NHMG), who ate ≥ 2 meals per day prepared outside home (n = 769). Daily diet quality was determined by energy intake, nutrient intake, Dietary Variety Score (DVS), and Diet Diversity Score (DDS).
Compared to the HMG, the NHMG was more likely to consist of men, single, employed, educated and of a higher economic status (all, P < 0.01). The NHMG showed higher energy intakes (1,776 vs. 2,116 kcal/day) with higher percentages of energy from protein (15 vs. 23%) and fat (14 vs. 16%) and lower intakes of dietary fiber, phosphorus, potassium, niacin, and vitamin C (all, P < 0.01) than the HMG, with some variations among age groups. The NHMG tended to consume foods prepared by frying and grilling and had more one-dish meals such as bibimbap, noodles, and dumplings but also showed higher dietary diversity.
It should be noted that home-made meals do not necessarily guarantee a healthy diet, and the effects of meal preparation location on nutritional status might vary depending on socio-demographic characteristics.
背景/目的:据报道,外出就餐对营养状况有负面影响。然而,外出就餐可能包括在家准备并在户外食用的餐食。相反,在家食用的餐食也可能是从外面带来的,因为外卖和送餐服务在韩国已变得很普遍。因此,我们测试了餐食准备地点是否会影响日常饮食质量。
对象/方法:从2007 - 2009年韩国国家健康与营养检查调查(KNHANES)中,4915名韩国成年人(20 - 64岁)被分为两组:自制餐食组(HMG),即每天至少食用2顿在家准备的餐食(n = 4146),以及非自制餐食组(NHMG),即每天至少食用2顿在家外准备的餐食(n = 769)。通过能量摄入、营养素摄入、饮食种类评分(DVS)和饮食多样性评分(DDS)来确定日常饮食质量。
与自制餐食组相比,非自制餐食组男性、单身、就业、受过教育且经济地位较高的比例更高(所有P < 0.01)。非自制餐食组的能量摄入量更高(1776 vs. 2116千卡/天),蛋白质(15% vs. 23%)和脂肪(14% vs. 16%)提供的能量百分比更高,膳食纤维、磷、钾、烟酸和维生素C的摄入量更低(所有P < 0.01),不同年龄组之间存在一些差异。非自制餐食组倾向于食用油炸和烤制的食物,并且有更多的单盘餐食,如石锅拌饭、面条和饺子,但饮食多样性也更高。
应注意的是,自制餐食不一定能保证健康饮食,餐食准备地点对营养状况的影响可能因社会人口学特征而异。