Wei Wang, Yuan-Yuan Jin, Ci Yan, Ahan Alayi, Ming-Qin Cao
Present Address: Department Epidemiology and Health Statistics, School of Public Health, Xinjiang Medical University, Urumqi, Xinjiang, China.
BMC Public Health. 2016 Oct 6;16(1):1058. doi: 10.1186/s12889-016-3723-4.
The spatial interplay between socioeconomic factors and tuberculosis (TB) cases contributes to the understanding of regional tuberculosis burdens. Historically, local Poisson Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR) has allowed for the identification of the geographic disparities of TB cases and their relevant socioeconomic determinants, thereby forecasting local regression coefficients for the relations between the incidence of TB and its socioeconomic determinants. Therefore, the aims of this study were to: (1) identify the socioeconomic determinants of geographic disparities of smear positive TB in Xinjiang, China (2) confirm if the incidence of smear positive TB and its associated socioeconomic determinants demonstrate spatial variability (3) compare the performance of two main models: one is Ordinary Least Square Regression (OLS), and the other local GWR model.
Reported smear-positive TB cases in Xinjiang were extracted from the TB surveillance system database during 2004-2010. The average number of smear-positive TB cases notified in Xinjiang was collected from 98 districts/counties. The population density (POPden), proportion of minorities (PROmin), number of infectious disease network reporting agencies (NUMagen), proportion of agricultural population (PROagr), and per capita annual gross domestic product (per capita GDP) were gathered from the Xinjiang Statistical Yearbook covering a period from 2004 to 2010. The OLS model and GWR model were then utilized to investigate socioeconomic determinants of smear-positive TB cases. Geoda 1.6.7, and GWR 4.0 software were used for data analysis.
Our findings indicate that the relations between the average number of smear-positive TB cases notified in Xinjiang and their socioeconomic determinants (POPden, PROmin, NUMagen, PROagr, and per capita GDP) were significantly spatially non-stationary. This means that in some areas more smear-positive TB cases could be related to higher socioeconomic determinant regression coefficients, but in some areas more smear-positive TB cases were found to do with lower socioeconomic determinant regression coefficients. We also found out that the GWR model could be better exploited to geographically differentiate the relationships between the average number of smear-positive TB cases and their socioeconomic determinants, which could interpret the dataset better (adjusted R = 0.912, AICc = 1107.22) than the OLS model (adjusted R = 0.768, AICc = 1196.74).
POPden, PROmin, NUMagen, PROagr, and per capita GDP are socioeconomic determinants of smear-positive TB cases. Comprehending the spatial heterogeneity of POPden, PROmin, NUMagen, PROagr, per capita GDP, and smear-positive TB cases could provide valuable information for TB precaution and control strategies.
社会经济因素与结核病病例之间的空间相互作用有助于理解区域结核病负担。从历史上看,局部泊松地理加权回归(GWR)能够识别结核病病例的地理差异及其相关的社会经济决定因素,从而预测结核病发病率与其社会经济决定因素之间关系的局部回归系数。因此,本研究的目的是:(1)确定中国新疆涂片阳性结核病地理差异的社会经济决定因素;(2)确认涂片阳性结核病发病率及其相关社会经济决定因素是否呈现空间变异性;(3)比较两个主要模型的性能:一个是普通最小二乘回归(OLS),另一个是局部GWR模型。
从2004 - 2010年结核病监测系统数据库中提取新疆报告的涂片阳性结核病病例。收集了新疆98个区县通报的涂片阳性结核病病例的平均数。人口密度(POPden)、少数民族比例(PROmin)、传染病网络报告机构数量(NUMagen)、农业人口比例(PROagr)以及人均国内生产总值(人均GDP)数据来自2004年至2010年的《新疆统计年鉴》。然后利用OLS模型和GWR模型研究涂片阳性结核病病例的社会经济决定因素。使用Geoda 1.6.7和GWR 4.0软件进行数据分析。
我们的研究结果表明,新疆通报的涂片阳性结核病病例平均数与其社会经济决定因素(POPden、PROmin、NUMagen、PROagr和人均GDP)之间的关系在空间上显著非平稳。这意味着在某些地区,更多的涂片阳性结核病病例可能与较高的社会经济决定因素回归系数相关,但在某些地区,更多的涂片阳性结核病病例却与较低的社会经济决定因素回归系数有关。我们还发现,GWR模型能够更好地从地理上区分涂片阳性结核病病例平均数与其社会经济决定因素之间的关系,与OLS模型(调整后R = 0.768,AICc = 1196.74)相比,它能更好地解释数据集(调整后R = 0.912,AICc = 1107.22)。
POPden、PROmin、NUMagen、PROagr和人均GDP是涂片阳性结核病病例的社会经济决定因素。了解POPden、PROmin、NUMagen、PROagr、人均GDP和涂片阳性结核病病例的空间异质性可为结核病预防和控制策略提供有价值的信息。