Deng Hongyong, Adams Clive E
Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China.
Cochrane Schizophrenia Group, Institute of Mental Health, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK.
Asia Pac Psychiatry. 2017 Mar;9(1). doi: 10.1111/appy.12265. Epub 2016 Oct 13.
To survey the reports of randomized trials of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) interventions for schizophrenia and produce a broad overview of this type of research activity in this area.
We searched the Cochrane Schizophrenia Group's comprehensive Trials Register (January 2016), selected all relevant randomized trials, and extracted the data within each study. Finally, we sought relevant reviews on the Cochrane Library.
We initially screened 423 articles from which we identified 378 relevant studies randomizing 35 341 participants (average study size 94, SD 60). There were 7 herbs used as single medicine, 4 compositions or extractions, more than 144 herbal mixes, and 7 TCM principles reported for schizophrenia. Nonpharmacological interventions of TCM included acupuncture and exercise. The most commonly evaluated treatments are Ginkgo biloba, acupuncture, Wendan decoction, and Shugan Jieyu Capsule. There are 3 directly relevant Cochrane reviews.
Most treatment approaches-and some in common use-have only one or two relevant small trials. Some coordination of effort would help ensure that further well-designed appropriately sized randomized trials are conducted. Systematic reviews should be performed in this field but with titles that take into account the complexity of TCM.
调查中医干预精神分裂症的随机试验报告,并对该领域此类研究活动进行全面概述。
我们检索了Cochrane精神分裂症组的综合试验注册库(2016年1月),筛选出所有相关随机试验,并提取每项研究中的数据。最后,我们在Cochrane图书馆查找相关综述。
我们初步筛选了423篇文章,从中确定了378项相关研究,涉及35341名参与者(平均研究规模为94,标准差为60)。有7种草药被用作单一药物,4种组合物或提取物,超过144种草药混合物,以及7种用于精神分裂症的中医原则。中医的非药物干预措施包括针灸和运动。最常评估的治疗方法是银杏叶、针灸、温胆汤和舒肝解郁胶囊。有3篇直接相关的Cochrane综述。
大多数治疗方法——包括一些常用方法——只有一两项相关的小型试验。一些协调工作将有助于确保开展进一步设计良好、规模适当的随机试验。该领域应进行系统综述,但标题应考虑到中医的复杂性。