Lubin J H, Boice J D
Epidemiology and Biostatistics Program, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD 20892.
Health Phys. 1989 Sep;57(3):417-27. doi: 10.1097/00004032-198909000-00008.
The proportion of lung cancer deaths attributable to Rn among residents of single-family homes in the U.S. (approximately 70% of the housing stock) is estimated using the log-normal distribution of Rn concentrations proposed by Nero et al. (1986) and the risk model developed by the National Academy of Sciences' BEIR IV Committee. The risk model, together with the exposure distribution, predicts that approximately 14% of lung cancer deaths among such residents (about 13,300 deaths per year, or 10% of all U.S. lung cancer deaths) may be due to indoor Rn exposure. The 95% confidence interval is 7%-25%, or approximately 6600 to 24,000 lung cancer deaths. These estimated attributable risks due to Rn are similar for males and females and for smokers and nonsmokers, but higher baseline risks of lung cancer result in much larger absolute numbers of Rn-attributable cancers among males (approximately 9000) and among smokers (approximately 11,000). Because of the apparent skewness of the exposure distribution, most of the contribution to the attributable risks arises from exposure rates below 148 Bq m-3 (4 pCi L-1), i.e., below the EPA "action level." As a result, if all exposure rates that exceed 148 Bq m-3 (approximately 8% of homes) were eliminated, the models predict that the total annual lung cancer burden in the U.S. would drop by 4-5%, or by about 3800 lung cancer deaths, in contrast to a maximum reduction of 14% if all indoor Rn exposure above the 1st percentile were eliminated.
利用内罗等人(1986年)提出的氡浓度对数正态分布以及美国国家科学院BEIR IV委员会开发的风险模型,估算了美国独栋住宅居民(约占住房存量的70%)中归因于氡的肺癌死亡比例。该风险模型与暴露分布一起预测,这类居民中约14%的肺癌死亡(每年约13300例死亡,占美国所有肺癌死亡的10%)可能归因于室内氡暴露。95%的置信区间为7%-25%,即约6600至24000例肺癌死亡。这些归因于氡的估计风险在男性和女性、吸烟者和非吸烟者中相似,但肺癌的较高基线风险导致男性(约9000例)和吸烟者(约11000例)中归因于氡的癌症绝对数量要大得多。由于暴露分布明显存在偏态,归因风险的大部分贡献来自低于148 Bq m-3(4 pCi L-1)的暴露率,即低于美国环境保护局的“行动水平”。因此,如果消除所有超过148 Bq m-3的暴露率(约占房屋的8%),模型预测美国每年的肺癌总负担将下降4%-5%,即约3800例肺癌死亡,相比之下,如果消除所有高于第1百分位数的室内氡暴露,最大降幅为14%。