Scheele Christian Elling, Little Ingvild, Diderichsen Finn
1 Department of Public Health, CESA/CHEP, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen K, Denmark.
2 The Norwegian WHO Healthy Cities Network, Oslo, Norway.
Scand J Public Health. 2018 Feb;46(1):57-67. doi: 10.1177/1403494816685538. Epub 2017 Jan 12.
Local governments in the Scandinavian countries are increasingly committed to reduce health inequity through 'health equity in all policies' (HEiAP) governance. There exists, however, only very sporadic implementation evidence concerning municipal HEiAP governance, which is the focus of this study.
Data are based on qualitative thematic network analysis of 20 interviews conducted from 2014 to 2015 with Scandinavian political and administrative practitioners.
We identify 24 factors located within three categories; political processes, where insufficient political commitment to health equity goals outside of the health sector and inadequate economic prioritization budget curbs implementation. Concerning evidence, there is a lack of epidemiological data, detailed evidence of health equity interventions as well as indicators relevant for monitoring implementation. Concerted administrative action relates to a lack of vertical support and alignment from the national and the regional level to the local level. Horizontally within the municipality, insufficient coordination across policy sectors inhibits effective health equity governance.
A shift away from 'health in all policies' based on a narrow health concept towards 'health equity for all policies' based on a broader concept such as 'sustainability' can improve ownership of health equity policy goals across municipal sectors.
斯堪的纳维亚国家的地方政府越来越致力于通过“所有政策中的健康公平”(HEiAP)治理来减少健康不平等。然而,关于城市HEiAP治理的实施证据非常零散,本研究聚焦于此。
数据基于2014年至2015年对斯堪的纳维亚政治和行政从业者进行的20次访谈的定性主题网络分析。
我们确定了三类中的24个因素;政治过程方面,卫生部门之外对健康公平目标的政治承诺不足以及经济优先事项预算不足限制了实施。在证据方面,缺乏流行病学数据、健康公平干预的详细证据以及与监测实施相关的指标。协同行政行动方面,国家和地区层面缺乏对地方层面的纵向支持和协调。在城市内部横向来看,政策部门之间缺乏充分协调阻碍了有效的健康公平治理。
从基于狭义健康概念的“所有政策中的健康”转向基于“可持续性”等更广泛概念的“所有政策中的健康公平”,可以提高城市各部门对健康公平政策目标的自主权。