Qi J, Trang T, Doong J, Kang S, Chien A L
Department of Dermatology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD.
Dermatol Online J. 2016 Nov 15;22(11):13030/qt7qc9z2m5.
Background Psoriasis patients seek information online, but little is known about their interaction with YouTube. We examined the quality of content in psoriasis-related YouTube videos and investigated their interactions with viewers.Methods YouTube was searched using the term "psoriasis." Relevant videos in English were independently categorized by two reviewers as useful, misleading, or patient view (regarding experience with psoriasis). Disagreements were settled by a third reviewer. Videos were rated on a Global Quality Scale (GQS) (1=poor, 5=excellent).Results According to our reviewers, 17% of the 47 videos were useful, 21% were misleading, and 62% represented patient views. Mean GQS scores were 4.2 ± 1.3 for useful videos, 1.7 ± 0.7 for misleading videos, and 2.2 ± 1.1 for patient view videos (p<0.001). Video views per day did not differ among the categories (p=0.65), whereas useful videos had fewest "Likes" (useful: 31 ± 55, 33 misleading: 151 ± 218, patient views: 165 ± 325, p=0.06) and comments (useful: 9.8 ± 18.3, misleading: 64.1 ± 89.7, 124.9 ± 34 199.4, p=0.009).Conclusions Useful videos were highest in quality but had similar viewership as misleading and patient view videos, with lower popularity and engagement of users compared to other categories. Physicians and psoriasis patients should be aware of this pattern when pproaching YouTube as a resource.
银屑病患者会在网上寻求信息,但对于他们与YouTube的互动情况却知之甚少。我们研究了银屑病相关YouTube视频的内容质量,并调查了这些视频与观众的互动情况。
在YouTube上搜索“银屑病”一词。两名评审员将相关英文视频独立分类为有用、误导性或患者视角(关于银屑病经历)。如有分歧,由第三名评审员解决。视频根据全球质量量表(GQS)进行评分(1=差,5=优秀)。
据我们的评审员判断,47个视频中17%有用,21%有误导性,62%代表患者视角。有用视频的GQS平均得分为4.2±1.3,误导性视频为1.7±0.7,患者视角视频为2.2±1.1(p<0.001)。各类视频的每日观看量无差异(p=0.65),而有用视频的“点赞”数最少(有用:31±55,误导性:151±218,患者视角:165±325,p=0.06),评论数也最少(有用:9.8±18.3,误导性:64.1±89.7,患者视角:124.9±199.4,p=0.009)。
有用视频质量最高,但观看量与误导性和患者视角视频相似,与其他类别相比,用户的受欢迎程度和参与度较低。医生和银屑病患者在将YouTube作为信息资源时应了解这种模式。