Puffer Eve S, Annan Jeannie, Sim Amanda L, Salhi Carmel, Betancourt Theresa S
Department of Psychology and Neuroscience, Duke Global Health Institute, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, United States of America.
Research, Evaluation, and Learning Technical Unit, The International Rescue Committee, New York, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2017 Mar 28;12(3):e0172611. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0172611. eCollection 2017.
To conduct a randomized controlled trial assessing the impact of a family-based intervention delivered to Burmese migrant families displaced in Thailand on parenting and family functioning.
Participants included 479 Burmese migrant families from 20 communities in Thailand. Families, including 513 caregivers and 479 children aged 7 to 15 years, were randomized to treatment and waitlist control groups. The treatment group received a 12-session family-based intervention delivered to groups of families by lay facilitators. Adapted standardized and locally derived measures were administered before and after the intervention to assess parent-child relationship quality, discipline practices, and family functioning.
Compared with controls, intervention families demonstrated improved quality of parent-child interactions on scales of parental warmth and affection (Effect size (ES) = 0.25 caregivers; 0.26 children, both p < 0.05) and negative relationship quality (ES = -0.37, p < 0.001 caregivers; -0.22 children, p < 0.05). Both children and caregivers also reported an effect on relationship quality based on a locally derived measure (ES = 0.40 caregivers, p < .001; 0.43 children, p < .05). Family functioning was improved, including family cohesion (ES = 0.46 caregivers; 0.36 children; both p < 0.001) and decreased negative interactions (ES = -0.30 caregivers, p < 0.01; -0.24 children, p < 0.05). Family communication also improved according to children only (ES = 0.29, p < 0.01). Caregivers, but not children, reported decreased harsh discipline (ES = -0.39, p < 0.001), and no effects were observed on use of positive discipline strategies. Treatment attendance was high, with participants attending a mean of 9.7 out of 12 sessions.
The intervention increased protective aspects of family well-being for migrant children and caregivers in a middle-income country. The strongest effects were on parent-child relationship quality and family functioning, while results were mixed on changes in discipline practices. Results suggest that a behavioral family-based approach implemented by lay providers in community settings is a promising intervention approach for strengthening families in highly stressed contexts.
Clinicaltrials.gov: NCT01668992.
开展一项随机对照试验,评估对泰国境内流离失所的缅甸移民家庭实施的家庭干预措施对养育子女及家庭功能的影响。
参与者包括来自泰国20个社区的479户缅甸移民家庭。这些家庭,包括513名照料者和479名7至15岁的儿童,被随机分为治疗组和等待名单对照组。治疗组由非专业促进者为多组家庭提供为期12节的家庭干预措施。在干预前后采用经过改编的标准化及本地制定的测量方法,以评估亲子关系质量、管教方式及家庭功能。
与对照组相比,干预组家庭在父母温暖与关爱量表(效应量(ES)=照料者为0.25;儿童为0.26,均p<0.05)及负面关系质量(ES=-0.37,照料者p<0.001;儿童为-0.22,p<0.05)方面,亲子互动质量有所改善。儿童和照料者还根据本地制定的测量方法报告了对关系质量的影响(ES=照料者为0.40,p<0.001;儿童为0.43,p<0.05)。家庭功能得到改善,包括家庭凝聚力(ES=照料者为0.46;儿童为0.36;均p<0.001)及负面互动减少(ES=照料者为-0.30,p<0.01;儿童为-0.24,p<0.05)。仅儿童报告家庭沟通有所改善(ES=0.29,p<0.01)。照料者报告严厉管教减少(ES=-0.39,p<0.001),但儿童未报告此情况,且在积极管教策略的使用方面未观察到效果。治疗出勤率很高,参与者平均参加了12节课程中的9.7节。
该干预措施增强了中等收入国家移民儿童和照料者家庭幸福的保护因素。最强的效果体现在亲子关系质量和家庭功能方面,而管教方式的变化结果不一。结果表明,由非专业提供者在社区环境中实施的基于行为家庭的方法是在高压力环境中加强家庭的一种有前景的干预方法。
Clinicaltrials.gov:NCT01668992。