Paul Susannah, Mgbere Osaro, Arafat Raouf, Yang Biru, Santos Eunice
Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA.
Houston Health Department, Houston, TX.
Online J Public Health Inform. 2017 Sep 8;9(2):e187. doi: 10.5210/ojphi.v9i2.8004. eCollection 2017.
Objective The objective was to forecast and validate prediction estimates of influenza activity in Houston, TX using four years of historical influenza-like illness (ILI) from three surveillance data capture mechanisms. Background Using novel surveillance methods and historical data to estimate future trends of influenza-like illness can lead to early detection of influenza activity increases and decreases. Anticipating surges gives public health professionals more time to prepare and increase prevention efforts. Methods Data was obtained from three surveillance systems, Flu Near You, ILINet, and hospital emergency center (EC) visits, with diverse data capture mechanisms. Autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) models were fitted to data from each source for week 27 of 2012 through week 26 of 2016 and used to forecast influenza-like activity for the subsequent 10 weeks. Estimates were then compared to actual ILI percentages for the same period. Results Forecasted estimates had wide confidence intervals that crossed zero. The forecasted trend direction differed by data source, resulting in lack of consensus about future influenza activity. ILINet forecasted estimates and actual percentages had the least differences. ILINet performed best when forecasting influenza activity in Houston, TX. Conclusion Though the three forecasted estimates did not agree on the trend directions, and thus, were considered imprecise predictors of long-term ILI activity based on existing data, pooling predictions and careful interpretations may be helpful for short term intervention efforts. Further work is needed to improve forecast accuracy considering the promise forecasting holds for seasonal influenza prevention and control, and pandemic preparedness.
目的 本研究旨在利用来自三种监测数据收集机制的四年历史流感样疾病(ILI)数据,预测并验证德克萨斯州休斯顿市流感活动的预测估计值。背景 使用新型监测方法和历史数据来估计流感样疾病的未来趋势,可早期发现流感活动的增加和减少。预测流感高峰可为公共卫生专业人员提供更多时间来做好准备并加强预防措施。方法 数据来自三个监测系统,即“身边的流感”、流感样疾病监测网络(ILINet)以及医院急诊中心就诊数据,这些系统的数据收集机制各不相同。对2012年第27周至2016年第26周每个数据源的数据拟合自回归积分滑动平均(ARIMA)模型,并用于预测随后10周的流感样活动。然后将估计值与同期的实际ILI百分比进行比较。结果 预测估计值的置信区间很宽且跨越了零点。不同数据源的预测趋势方向不同,导致对于未来流感活动缺乏共识。ILINet的预测估计值与实际百分比之间的差异最小。在预测德克萨斯州休斯顿市的流感活动时,ILINet表现最佳。结论 尽管三种预测估计值在趋势方向上不一致,因此基于现有数据被认为是长期ILI活动的不精确预测指标,但汇总预测结果并进行仔细解读可能有助于短期干预措施。鉴于预测对季节性流感预防控制和大流行防范的前景,需要进一步开展工作以提高预测准确性。