Milner Julia, Arezina Jane
1Rotherham NHS Foundation Trust, Rotherham, UK.
2University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Ultrasound. 2018 Feb;26(1):32-41. doi: 10.1177/1742271X17732807. Epub 2018 Feb 7.
Ultrasound estimation of fetal weight is a highly influential factor in antenatal management, guiding both the timing and mode of delivery of a pregnancy. Although substantial research has investigated the most accurate ultrasound formula for calculating estimated fetal weight, current evidence indicates significant error levels. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the most accurate method, whilst identifying sources of inaccuracy in order to facilitate recommendations for future practice. Seven studies met the inclusion criteria and 11 different formulae were assessed; ultrasound calculation of fetal weight was most commonly overestimated. The Hadlock A formula produced the most accurate results, with the lowest levels of random error. Methods incorporating just two measurement parameters were inconsistent, producing large random errors across multiple studies. Key sources of inaccuracy included difficulties obtaining accurate fetal measurements in late gestation; the remainder were operator dependent, including lack of experience and insufficient training and audit. The accuracy of ultrasound estimated fetal weight has improved in the last decade, though a lack of consistency remains evident. National implementation of a rigorous audit programme would likely improve accuracy further, and increase the confidence and clinical value of the method.
超声估计胎儿体重是产前管理中的一个极具影响力的因素,它指导着妊娠的分娩时间和方式。尽管已有大量研究探讨了计算估计胎儿体重的最准确超声公式,但目前的证据表明存在显著的误差水平。本系统评价的目的是确定最准确的方法,同时找出不准确的来源,以便为未来的实践提供建议。七项研究符合纳入标准,评估了11种不同的公式;超声计算胎儿体重最常见的情况是被高估。哈德洛克A公式产生了最准确的结果,随机误差水平最低。仅包含两个测量参数的方法不一致,在多项研究中产生了较大的随机误差。不准确的主要来源包括在妊娠晚期难以获得准确的胎儿测量值;其余则取决于操作者,包括缺乏经验、培训不足和审核不够。在过去十年中,超声估计胎儿体重的准确性有所提高,不过缺乏一致性仍然很明显。在全国范围内实施严格的审核计划可能会进一步提高准确性,并增加该方法的可信度和临床价值。