Alonso Carolina Maria do Carmo, Béguin Pascal Daniel, Duarte Francisco José de Castro Moura
Departamento de Terapia Ocupacional, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brasil.
Institut D'Etudes du Travail, Université Lumière Lyon 2, Lyon, France.
Rev Saude Publica. 2018;52:14. doi: 10.11606/s1518-8787.2018052000395. Epub 2018 Feb 26.
OBJECTIVE To systematize and analyze the evidence from qualitative studies that address the perception of Brazilian Community Health Agents about their work. METHODS This is a systematic review of the meta-synthesis type on the work of community health agents, carried out from the Virtual Health Library using the descriptors "Agente Comunitário de Saúde" and "Trabalho", in Portuguese. The strategy was constructed by crossing descriptors, using the Boolean operator "AND", and filtering Brazilian articles, published from 2004 to 2014, which resulted in 129 identified articles. We removed quantitative or quanti-qualitative research articles, essays, debates, literature reviews, reports of experiences, and research that did not include Brazilian Community Health Agents as subjects. Using these criteria, we selected and analyzed 33 studies that allowed us to identify common subjects and differences between them, to group the main conclusions, to classify subjects, and to interpret the content. RESULTS The analysis resulted in three thematic units: characteristics of the work of community health agents, problems related to the work of community health agents, and positive aspects of the work of community health agents. On the characteristics, we could see that the work of the community health agents is permeated by the political and social dimensions of the health work with predominant use of light technologies. The main input is the knowledge that this professional obtains with the contact with families, which is developed with home visits. On the problems in the work of community health agents, we could identify the lack of limits in their attributions, poor conditions, obstacles in the relationship with the community and teams, weak professional training, and bureaucracy. The positive aspects we identified were the recognition of the work by families, resolution, bonding, work with peers, and work close to home. CONCLUSIONS This review provided an overview of the difficulties and positive aspects that are present in the daily work of community health agents. Given this, we have raised two challenges. The first one refers to how public policy makers need to appropriation the research results and the second one refers to the need to invest in studies that are designed to generate solutions for the difficulties faced by community health agents in their work.
目的 对定性研究中的证据进行系统整理和分析,这些研究涉及巴西社区卫生工作者对其工作的认知。方法 这是一项关于社区卫生工作者工作的元综合类型的系统评价,通过虚拟健康图书馆,使用葡萄牙语描述词“社区卫生工作者”和“工作”进行。该策略通过交叉描述词构建,使用布尔运算符“AND”,并筛选2004年至2014年发表的巴西文章,共识别出129篇文章。我们剔除了定量或定量 - 定性研究文章、论文、辩论、文献综述、经验报告以及未将巴西社区卫生工作者作为研究对象的研究。使用这些标准,我们选择并分析了33项研究,从而能够识别共同主题及其差异、归纳主要结论、对主题进行分类并解读内容。结果 分析得出三个主题单元:社区卫生工作者工作的特点、与社区卫生工作者工作相关的问题以及社区卫生工作者工作的积极方面。在特点方面,我们可以看到社区卫生工作者的工作受到卫生工作的政治和社会层面的影响,主要使用轻型技术。主要的信息来源是该专业人员与家庭接触所获得的知识,这通过家访得以发展。在社区卫生工作者工作中的问题方面,我们可以识别出其职责缺乏明确界限、条件不佳、与社区和团队关系中的障碍、专业培训薄弱以及官僚作风。我们确定的积极方面包括家庭对工作的认可、解决问题、建立联系、与同行合作以及离家近的工作地点。结论 本综述概述了社区卫生工作者日常工作中存在的困难和积极方面。鉴于此,我们提出了两个挑战。第一个挑战涉及公共政策制定者如何运用研究结果,第二个挑战涉及需要投资开展旨在为社区卫生工作者工作中面临的困难生成解决方案的研究。