Department of Psychiatry, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, NY, USA.
Psychiatry Res. 2018 May;263:74-79. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2018.02.037. Epub 2018 Feb 17.
Although rating scales to assess formal thought disorder exist, there are no objective, high-reliability instruments that can quantify and track it. This proof-of-concept study shows that CoVec, a new automated tool, is able to differentiate between controls and patients with schizophrenia with derailment and tangentiality. According to ratings from the derailment and tangentiality items of the Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms, we divided the sample into three groups: controls, patients without formal thought disorder, and patients with derailment/tangentiality. Their lists of animals produced during a one-minute semantic fluency task were processed using CoVec, a newly developed software that measures the semantic similarity of words based on vector semantic analysis. CoVec outputs were Mean Similarity, Coherence, Coherence-5, and Coherence-10. Patients with schizophrenia produced fewer words than controls. Patients with derailment had a significantly lower mean number of words and lower Coherence-5 than controls and patients without derailment. Patients with tangentiality had significantly lower Coherence-5 and Coherence-10 than controls and patients without tangentiality. Despite the small samples of patients with clinically apparent thought disorder, CoVec was able to detect subtle differences between controls and patients with either or both of the two forms of disorganization.
虽然有评估正式思维障碍的量表,但目前还没有能够量化和跟踪思维障碍的客观、高可靠性工具。这项概念验证研究表明,新型自动化工具 CoVec 能够区分精神分裂症患者和对照组的思维奔逸和离题。根据阳性症状评估量表中思维奔逸和离题项目的评分,我们将样本分为三组:对照组、无正式思维障碍的患者组和有思维奔逸/离题的患者组。他们在一分钟语义流畅性任务中生成的动物列表使用 CoVec 进行处理,这是一种新开发的软件,基于向量语义分析来衡量单词的语义相似度。CoVec 的输出结果为平均相似度、连贯性、连贯性-5 和连贯性-10。精神分裂症患者生成的单词数少于对照组。有思维奔逸的患者的平均单词数和连贯性-5 明显低于对照组和无思维奔逸的患者。有离题的患者的连贯性-5 和连贯性-10 明显低于对照组和无离题的患者。尽管有明显思维障碍的患者样本量较小,但 CoVec 仍能够检测到对照组和两种形式紊乱患者之间的细微差异。