Department of Psychology, Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs, United States of America.
Department of Mathematics, Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2018 Apr 9;13(4):e0195503. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0195503. eCollection 2018.
While there is substantial evidence that adults who violate gender stereotypes often face backlash (i.e. social and economic penalties), less is known about the nature of gender stereotypes for young children, and the penalties that children may face for violating them. We conducted three experiments, with over 2000 adults from the US, to better understand the content and consequences of adults' gender stereotypes for young children. In Experiment 1, we tested which characteristics adults (N = 635) believed to be descriptive (i.e. typical), prescriptive (i.e. required), and proscriptive (i.e. forbidden) for preschool-aged boys and girls. Using the characteristics that were rated in Experiment 1, we then constructed vignettes that were either 'masculine' or 'feminine', and manipulated whether the vignettes were said to describe a boy or a girl. Experiment 2 (N = 697) revealed that adults rated stereotype-violating children as less likeable than their stereotype-conforming peers, and that this difference was more robust for boys than girls. Experiment 3 (N = 731) was a direct replication of Experiment 2, and revealed converging evidence of backlash against stereotype-violating children. In sum, our results suggest that even young children encounter backlash from adults for stereotype violations, and that these effects may be strongest for boys.
虽然有大量证据表明,违反性别刻板印象的成年人经常会面临负面反应(即社会和经济惩罚),但对于幼儿的性别刻板印象的本质以及儿童因违反这些刻板印象而可能面临的惩罚,了解较少。我们进行了三项实验,共有来自美国的 2000 多名成年人参与,以更好地了解成年人对幼儿的性别刻板印象的内容和后果。在实验 1 中,我们测试了成年人(N=635)认为哪些特征对学龄前男孩和女孩具有描述性(即典型)、规定性(即必需)和禁止性(即禁止)。然后,我们使用实验 1 中评定的特征,构建了被认为是“男性化”或“女性化”的情景,并操纵情景是描述男孩还是女孩。实验 2(N=697)显示,成年人认为违反刻板印象的孩子不如其符合刻板印象的同龄人更讨人喜欢,而且这种差异对于男孩比女孩更为明显。实验 3(N=731)是实验 2 的直接复制,显示出对违反刻板印象的孩子的负面反应的证据一致。总之,我们的研究结果表明,即使是幼儿也会因为违反刻板印象而受到成年人的负面反应,而且这种影响对于男孩来说可能更强。