Grecequet Martina, DeWaard Jack, Hellmann Jessica J, Abel Guy J
Institute on the Environment, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108, USA.
Department of Sociology and Minnesota Population Center, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA.
Sustainability. 2017 May;9(5). doi: 10.3390/su9050720. Epub 2017 Apr 30.
The relationship between climate change and human migration is not homogenous and depends critically on the differential vulnerability of population and places. If places and populations are not vulnerable, or susceptible, to climate change, then the climate-migration relationship may not materialize. The key to understanding and, from a policy perspective, planning for whether and how climate change will impact future migration patterns is therefore knowledge of the link between climate vulnerability and migration. However, beyond specific case studies, little is known about this association in global perspective. We therefore provide a descriptive, country-level portrait of this relationship. We show that the negative association between climate vulnerability and international migration holds only for countries least vulnerable to climate change, which suggests the potential for trapped populations in more vulnerable countries. However, when analyzed separately by life supporting sector (food, water, health, ecosystem services, human habitat, and infrastructure) and vulnerability dimension (exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity), we detect evidence of a relationship among more, but not the most, vulnerable countries. The bilateral (i.e., country-to-country) migration show that, on average, people move from countries of higher vulnerability to lower vulnerability, reducing global risk by 15%. This finding is consistent with the idea that migration is a climate adaptation strategy. Still, ~6% of bilateral migration is maladaptive with respect to climate change, with some movement toward countries with greater climate change vulnerability.
气候变化与人类迁移之间的关系并非一成不变,这在很大程度上取决于不同人群和地区的脆弱性差异。如果某些地区和人群对气候变化不敏感,那么气候变化与迁移之间的关系可能就不会显现出来。因此,从政策角度理解和规划气候变化是否以及如何影响未来迁移模式的关键在于了解气候脆弱性与迁移之间的联系。然而,除了具体的案例研究之外,从全球视角来看,人们对这种关联知之甚少。因此,我们提供了一份关于这种关系的国家层面的描述性概况。我们发现,气候脆弱性与国际迁移之间的负相关关系仅适用于那些对气候变化最不脆弱的国家,这表明在更脆弱的国家可能存在被困人口。然而,当按生命支持部门(粮食、水、健康、生态系统服务、人类栖息地和基础设施)以及脆弱性维度(暴露度、敏感度和适应能力)分别进行分析时,我们在更多但并非最脆弱的国家中发现了两者之间关系的证据。双边(即国家与国家之间)迁移情况表明,平均而言,人们会从脆弱性较高的国家迁往脆弱性较低的国家,从而使全球风险降低了15%。这一发现与迁移是一种气候适应策略的观点相一致。尽管如此,约6%的双边迁移在应对气候变化方面是适应不良的,即存在一些向气候变化脆弱性更高国家的迁移情况。