Aebersold Michelle, Voepel-Lewis Terri, Cherara Leila, Weber Monica, Khouri Christina, Levine Robert, Tait Alan R
Clinical Associate Professor Department of Systems, Populations and Leadership, Director Simulation and Educational Innovation, 426 N. Ingalls, University of Michigan, School of Nursing, Ann Arbor, MI 48109.
Associate Research Scientist, Department of Anesthesiology, 1500 E. Medical Center Drive, Ann Arbor, MI 48109.
Clin Simul Nurs. 2018 Feb;15:34-41. doi: 10.1016/j.ecns.2017.09.008.
Traditionally, clinical psychomotor skills are taught through videos and demonstration by faculty which does not allow for the visualization of internal structures and anatomical landmarks that would enhance the learner skill performance.
Sophomore and junior nursing students attending a large Midwestern Institution (N=69) participated in this mixed methods study. Students demonstrated their ability to place a nasogastric tube (NGT) after being randomly assigned to usual training (Control group) or an iPad anatomy-augmented virtual simulation training module (AR group). The ability of the participants to demonstrate competence in placing the NGT was assessed using a 17-item competency checklist. After the demonstration, students completed a survey to elicit information about students' level of training, prior experience with NGT placement, satisfaction with the AR technology, and perceptions of AR as a potential teaching tool for clinical skills training.
The ability to correctly place the NGT through all the checklist items was statistically significant in the AR group compared with the control group (P = 0.011). Eighty-six percent of participants in the AR group rated AR as superior/far superior to other procedural training programs to which they had been exposed, whereas, only 5.9% of participants in the control group rated the control program as superior/far superior (P < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS: Overall the AR module was better received compared with the control group with regards to realism, identifying landmarks, visualization of internal organs, ease of use, usefulness, and promoting learning and understanding.
传统上,临床心理运动技能是通过视频和教员演示来教授的,这无法实现对内部结构和解剖学标志的可视化,而这些有助于提高学习者的技能表现。
就读于中西部一所大型院校的大二和大三护理专业学生(N = 69)参与了这项混合方法研究。学生们在被随机分配到常规培训组(对照组)或iPad解剖增强虚拟模拟培训模块组(增强现实组)后,展示了他们放置鼻胃管(NGT)的能力。使用一份包含17项内容的能力清单评估参与者展示放置NGT能力的情况。演示结束后,学生们完成了一项调查,以获取有关学生培训水平、既往放置NGT的经验、对增强现实技术的满意度以及对增强现实作为临床技能培训潜在教学工具的看法等信息。
与对照组相比,增强现实组在所有清单项目上正确放置NGT的能力具有统计学意义(P = 0.011)。增强现实组中86%的参与者将增强现实评为优于/远优于他们之前接触过的其他程序培训项目,而对照组中只有5.9%的参与者将对照项目评为优于/远优于(P < 0.001)。
结论/启示:总体而言,在真实性、识别标志、内部器官可视化、易用性、实用性以及促进学习和理解方面,增强现实模块比对照组更受欢迎。