1 Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA, USA.
Health Educ Behav. 2019 Apr;46(2):197-203. doi: 10.1177/1090198118806965. Epub 2018 Oct 25.
Understanding how two characteristics-flavors and modified risk messages-affect perceptions and subjective effects of electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) can inform tobacco control efforts. In two within-subjects studies ( N = 17 and N = 19), the effects of e-cigarette flavors (tobacco vs. menthol and unflavored vs. cherry) and hypothetical modified risk messages ("reduced harm relative to cigarettes" vs. no message and "reduced carcinogen exposure relative to cigarettes" vs. no message) on cigarette smokers' perceptions of e-cigarettes were measured after participants self-administered condition-specific products (own-brand cigarettes; e-cigarettes). Perceptions/subjective effects were tested using linear mixed-effects regressions. Cigarettes were perceived as most harmful but rated more positively than e-cigarettes ( ps < .05). Cherry and menthol e-cigarettes increased perceived pleasantness, taste, and physical sensations compared with unflavored and tobacco-flavored e-cigarettes, respectively ( ps < .05). Modified risk messages were associated with reduced ratings of aversive effects ( ps < .05) but not harm perceptions. Overall, few perceptions/subjective effects differed by e-cigarette flavor or message. Flavors and messages may have some influence on how smokers experience e-cigarettes.
了解两种特性——口味和修改后的风险信息——如何影响电子烟(e-cigarettes)的认知和主观感受,可以为烟草控制工作提供信息。在两项内被试研究中(N=17 和 N=19),在参与者自行使用特定条件产品(自有品牌香烟;电子烟)后,测量了电子烟口味(烟草味与薄荷味和无味与樱桃味)和假设的修改后风险信息(“与香烟相比危害降低”与“无信息”和“与香烟相比致癌物暴露降低”与“无信息”)对吸烟者对电子烟的认知的影响。使用线性混合效应回归测试认知/主观效果。香烟被认为是最有害的,但比电子烟(p<0.05)的评价更高。与无味和烟草味的电子烟相比,樱桃味和薄荷味的电子烟增加了感知的愉悦感、口感和身体感觉(p<0.05)。修改后的风险信息与降低的不良影响评分相关(p<0.05),但与危害认知无关。总体而言,电子烟口味或信息对电子烟的体验很少有不同的认知/主观影响。口味和信息可能会对吸烟者体验电子烟产生一些影响。