Pellegrini Enrico, Ballerini Lucia, Hernandez Maria Del C Valdes, Chappell Francesca M, González-Castro Victor, Anblagan Devasuda, Danso Samuel, Muñoz-Maniega Susana, Job Dominic, Pernet Cyril, Mair Grant, MacGillivray Tom J, Trucco Emanuele, Wardlaw Joanna M
Division of Neuroimaging, Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences and Edinburgh Imaging, University of Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.
Department of Electrical, Systems and Automatics Engineering, Universidad de León, León, Spain.
Alzheimers Dement (Amst). 2018 Aug 11;10:519-535. doi: 10.1016/j.dadm.2018.07.004. eCollection 2018.
Advanced machine learning methods might help to identify dementia risk from neuroimaging, but their accuracy to date is unclear.
We systematically reviewed the literature, 2006 to late 2016, for machine learning studies differentiating healthy aging from dementia of various types, assessing study quality, and comparing accuracy at different disease boundaries.
Of 111 relevant studies, most assessed Alzheimer's disease versus healthy controls, using AD Neuroimaging Initiative data, support vector machines, and only T1-weighted sequences. Accuracy was highest for differentiating Alzheimer's disease from healthy controls and poor for differentiating healthy controls versus mild cognitive impairment versus Alzheimer's disease or mild cognitive impairment converters versus nonconverters. Accuracy increased using combined data types, but not by data source, sample size, or machine learning method.
Machine learning does not differentiate clinically relevant disease categories yet. More diverse data sets, combinations of different types of data, and close clinical integration of machine learning would help to advance the field.
先进的机器学习方法可能有助于从神经影像学中识别痴呆风险,但目前其准确性尚不清楚。
我们系统回顾了2006年至2016年末的文献,以查找区分健康衰老与各种类型痴呆的机器学习研究,评估研究质量,并比较不同疾病界限下的准确性。
在111项相关研究中,大多数使用阿尔茨海默病神经影像学计划数据、支持向量机且仅采用T1加权序列来评估阿尔茨海默病与健康对照。区分阿尔茨海默病与健康对照时准确性最高,而区分健康对照与轻度认知障碍、阿尔茨海默病,或轻度认知障碍转化者与未转化者时准确性较差。使用组合数据类型时准确性提高,但不受数据源、样本量或机器学习方法的影响。
机器学习尚未能区分临床相关的疾病类别。更多样化的数据集、不同类型数据的组合以及机器学习与临床的紧密结合将有助于推动该领域的发展。