Angle Orthod. 2019 May;89(3):372-377. doi: 10.2319/041218-274.1. Epub 2019 Feb 5.
To compare the esthetic improvement between postorthodontic white-spot lesions (WSLs) treated by resin infiltration and microabrasion for 12 months.
A total of 20 patients with 128 teeth with postorthodontic WSLs were recruited. A simple randomized, split-mouth, positive controlled design was used to allocate patients to resin infiltration or microabrasion groups. The lesion area ratio (R value) was calculated between the area of a WSL and the labial surface of the corresponding tooth based on standardized clinical photographs. The color change (Δ) of each tooth was measured with a Crystaleye spectrophotometer (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan). Every measurement was taken before treatment (T0) and at different time points after treatment: 1 week (T1), 6 months (T6), and 12 months (T12).
A total of 16 patients with 108 trial teeth were available at T12. Each group had 54 trial teeth. In both groups, there was a significant decrease in R value and Δ between T1 and T0 ( < .0001). In the infiltration group, the R value and Δ had no significant changes over time from T1 to T12. In the microabrasion group, the R value and Δ decreased significantly from T1 to T6. The R value of resin infiltration was lower when compared with microabrasion at every recall point ( < .001). The Δ had no significant differences between the two groups at any timepoint.
Resin infiltration and microabrasion improved the esthetic appearance of WSLs and showed sufficient durability for 12 months. Resin infiltration showed a better esthetic improvement effect when compared with microabrasion at 12 months.
比较正畸后釉质白斑(WSL)经树脂渗透和微磨蚀处理后 12 个月的美学改善效果。
共纳入 20 名正畸后有 128 颗 WSL 的患者。采用简单随机、分侧、阳性对照设计,将患者分为树脂渗透组或微磨蚀组。基于标准化临床照片,计算 WSL 面积与相应牙齿唇面的比值(R 值)。使用 Crystaleye 分光光度计(Olympus,Tokyo,Japan)测量每颗牙齿的颜色变化(Δ)。每次测量均在治疗前(T0)和治疗后不同时间点进行:1 周(T1)、6 个月(T6)和 12 个月(T12)。
在 T12 时,共有 16 名患者的 108 颗试验牙可用。每组有 54 颗试验牙。两组中,R 值和Δ在 T1 与 T0 之间均显著降低(<0.0001)。在渗透组中,从 T1 到 T12,R 值和Δ无明显变化。在微磨蚀组中,R 值和Δ从 T1 到 T6 显著降低。在每次随访时,树脂渗透的 R 值均低于微磨蚀(<0.001)。两组在任何时间点的Δ均无显著差异。
树脂渗透和微磨蚀均改善了 WSL 的美观效果,12 个月时具有足够的耐用性。树脂渗透在 12 个月时的美学改善效果优于微磨蚀。