Hashimoto Yohei, Inoue Tatsuya, Ono Takashi, Lee Jinhee, Tsuneyoshi Saori, Fujita Asahi, Inoue Yuji, Ogawa Shun, Asaoka Ryo, Obata Ryo
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Tokyo Graduate School of Medicine, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan.
Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2019 Feb 11;8(1):20. doi: 10.1167/tvst.8.1.20. eCollection 2019 Jan.
To assess precision and accuracy of a new objective algorithm using binarization in a software for identifying the hyperautofluorescent ring (AF ring) in retinitis pigmentosa (RP) compared with subjective visual inspection.
Ultra-widefield AF images were obtained from 23 eyes of 13 patients with retinitis pigmentosa (RP). We defined the borders of the AF rings using semiautomatic binarization algorithm in Fiji software. We compared the degree of precision (intra- and interrater agreements) of this algorithm and that of subjective visual inspection (freehand method) using Jaccard indices (JIs). To compare the classification performance (whether 68 points of Humphrey Field Analyzer is classified as inside, on, or outside AF rings), we calculated percent agreement and weighted kappa statistic between the two methods. The relationship between the distance from the AF ring and retinal sensitivities was also investigated.
The binarization method showed significantly higher JIs than the freehand method (for interrater: 0.94-0.95 vs. 0.73-0.78, respectively, = 0.002; for intrarater: 0.95 vs. 0.68-0.71, respectively, = 0.005). Percent agreement for classification between the two methods were 0.94 and weighted kappa statistic was 0.94 ( < 0.001). The retinal sensitivities decreased significantly and eccentrically from 2° inside to 3° outside the AF ring.
Defining the AF ring in RP using the binarization algorithm showed significantly higher precision and the same degree of accuracy compared with visual inspection.
This novel method may enable quantitative analysis of the AF ring, an indicator of retinal function in RP.
在一款用于识别色素性视网膜炎(RP)中超自发荧光环(AF环)的软件中,评估一种使用二值化的新客观算法相对于主观视觉检查的精度和准确性。
从13例色素性视网膜炎(RP)患者的23只眼中获取超广角AF图像。我们在Fiji软件中使用半自动二值化算法定义AF环的边界。我们使用杰卡德指数(JIs)比较该算法与主观视觉检查(徒手方法)的精度程度(评分者间和评分者内一致性)。为了比较分类性能(汉弗莱视野分析仪的68个点是否被分类为在AF环内、在AF环上或在AF环外),我们计算了两种方法之间的一致百分比和加权kappa统计量。还研究了AF环与视网膜敏感度之间的距离关系。
二值化方法显示的JIs显著高于徒手方法(评分者间:分别为0.94 - 0.95对0.73 - 0.78,P = 0.002;评分者内:分别为0.95对0.68 - 0.71,P = 0.005)。两种方法之间分类的一致百分比为0.94,加权kappa统计量为0.94(P < 0.001)。从AF环内2°到AF环外3°,视网膜敏感度显著且呈偏心性下降。
与视觉检查相比,使用二值化算法在RP中定义AF环显示出显著更高的精度和相同程度的准确性。
这种新方法可能使对AF环进行定量分析成为可能,AF环是RP中视网膜功能的一个指标。