Kalmijn Matthijs
1Department of Sociology, University of Amsterdam, Nieuwe Achtergracht 166, 1018 WV Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
2Netherlands Interdisciplinary Demographic Institute (NIDI), The Hague, The Netherlands.
Eur J Popul. 2018 Apr 9;35(2):263-284. doi: 10.1007/s10680-018-9472-6. eCollection 2019 May.
There has been debate about whether the flow of intergenerational support reverses as parents age. One view is that in western countries, parents remain 'net donors' to children, even in very old age. Such a conclusion coincides with notions of parental altruism and would be in contrast to notions of exchange and reciprocity over the life course. This paper examines the thesis of flow reversal in a new way: it uses prospective longitudinal data, it combines data from samples of ageing parents and samples of adult children, it develops a way to create measures of balance from frequency items on support exchange, and it combines objective measures of support exchange with subjective perceptions of symmetry. The focus is limited to support that involves time and effort. The support that parents give to children declines with age, the support they receive increases, and at around age 75-76, parents become 'net receivers'. The decline in downward support is stronger than the increase in upward support, suggesting that declining parental opportunities to give plays an important role in the flow reversal. In sum, the analyses provide evidence for what we can call delayed and parent-driven flow reversal. Evidence for flow reversal is stronger in the sample of adult children, pointing to the limitations of sampling ageing parents. Finally, there is correspondence between objective measures of support exchange and perceptions of symmetry, although on the whole, few parents regard themselves as 'net receivers'.
关于代际支持的流向是否会随着父母年龄增长而逆转,一直存在争议。一种观点认为,在西方国家,即使父母年事已高,他们仍是子女的“净给予者”。这一结论与父母利他主义的观念相符,并且与一生中交换和互惠的观念形成对比。本文以一种新的方式研究了流向逆转的论点:它使用前瞻性纵向数据,将老年父母样本和成年子女样本的数据相结合,开发了一种从支持交换的频率项目中创建平衡度量的方法,并将支持交换的客观度量与对称的主观认知相结合。重点仅限于涉及时间和精力的支持。父母给予子女的支持随年龄增长而减少,他们得到的支持增加,在大约75 - 76岁时,父母成为“净接受者”。向下支持的减少幅度大于向上支持的增加幅度,这表明父母给予支持的机会减少在流向逆转中起了重要作用。总之,分析为我们所谓的延迟且由父母驱动的流向逆转提供了证据。流向逆转的证据在成年子女样本中更强,这指出了抽取老年父母样本的局限性。最后,支持交换的客观度量与对称认知之间存在对应关系,不过总体而言,很少有父母认为自己是“净接受者”。