Song Tae Jin, Lee Mi Ji, Choi Yun Ju, Kim Byung Kun, Chung Pil Wook, Park Jung Wook, Chu Min Kyung, Kim Byung Su, Sohn Jong Hee, Oh Kyungmi, Kim Daeyoung, Kim Jae Moon, Kim Soo Kyoung, Park Kwang Yeol, Chung Jae Myun, Moon Heui Soo, Chung Chin Sang, Ahn Jin Young, Cho Soo Jin
Department of Neurology, Ewha Womans University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Department of Neurology, Neuroscience Center, Samsung Medical Center, Sungkyunkwan University School of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
J Clin Neurol. 2019 Jul;15(3):334-338. doi: 10.3988/jcn.2019.15.3.334.
Cluster headache (CH) can present with migrainous symptoms such as nausea, photophobia, and phonophobia. In addition, an overlap between CH and migraine has been reported. This study aimed to determine the differences in the characteristics of CH according to the presence of comorbid migraine.
This study was performed using data from a prospective multicenter registry study of CH involving 16 headache clinics. CH and migraine were diagnosed by headache specialists at each hospital based on third edition of the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3). We interviewed patients with comorbid migraine to obtain detailed information about migraine. The characteristics and psychological comorbidities of CH were compared between patients with and without comorbid migraine.
Thirty (15.6%) of 192 patients with CH had comorbid migraine, comprising 18 with migraine without aura, 1 with migraine with aura, 3 with chronic migraine, and 8 with probable migraine. Compared to patients with CH without migraine, patients with CH with comorbid migraine had a shorter duration of CH after the first episode [5.4±7.4 vs. 9.0±8.2 years (mean±standard deviation), =0.008], a lower frequency of episodic CH (50.0% vs. 73.5%, =0.010), and a higher frequency of chronic CH (13.3% vs. 3.7%, =0.033). Psychiatric comorbidities did not differ between patients with and without comorbid migraine. The headaches experienced by patients could be distinguished based on their trigeminal autonomic symptoms, pulsating character, severity, and pain location.
Distinct characteristics of CH remained unchanged in patients with comorbid migraine with the exception of an increased frequency of chronic CH. The most appropriate management of CH requires clinicians to check the history of preceding migraine, particularly in cases of chronic CH.
丛集性头痛(CH)可伴有偏头痛症状,如恶心、畏光和畏声。此外,已有报道称CH与偏头痛存在重叠。本研究旨在确定合并偏头痛时CH特征的差异。
本研究使用了来自一项前瞻性多中心CH注册研究的数据,该研究涉及16个头痛诊所。各医院的头痛专家根据《国际头痛疾病分类》第三版(ICHD - 3)诊断CH和偏头痛。我们对合并偏头痛的患者进行访谈,以获取有关偏头痛的详细信息。比较了合并偏头痛和未合并偏头痛的CH患者的特征及心理共病情况。
192例CH患者中有30例(15.6%)合并偏头痛,其中18例为无先兆偏头痛,1例为有先兆偏头痛,3例为慢性偏头痛,8例为可能的偏头痛。与未合并偏头痛的CH患者相比,合并偏头痛的CH患者首次发作后CH的病程较短[5.4±7.4 vs. 9.0±8.2年(均值±标准差),P = 0.008],发作性CH的频率较低(50.0% vs. 73.5%,P = 0.010),慢性CH的频率较高(13.3% vs. 3.7%,P = 0.033)。合并偏头痛和未合并偏头痛的患者在精神共病方面无差异。患者经历的头痛可根据其三叉神经自主症状、搏动性特征、严重程度和疼痛部位进行区分。
合并偏头痛的患者中,除慢性CH频率增加外,CH的独特特征保持不变。CH的最恰当管理要求临床医生检查既往偏头痛病史,尤其是在慢性CH病例中。