Lonini Luca, Dai Andrew, Shawen Nicholas, Simuni Tanya, Poon Cynthia, Shimanovich Leo, Daeschler Margaret, Ghaffari Roozbeh, Rogers John A, Jayaraman Arun
Max Nader Lab for Rehabilitation Technologies and Outcomes Research, Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Chicago, IL 60611 USA.
2Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL 60611 USA.
NPJ Digit Med. 2018 Nov 23;1:64. doi: 10.1038/s41746-018-0071-z. eCollection 2018.
Machine learning algorithms that use data streams captured from soft wearable sensors have the potential to automatically detect PD symptoms and inform clinicians about the progression of disease. However, these algorithms must be trained with annotated data from clinical experts who can recognize symptoms, and collecting such data are costly. Understanding how many sensors and how much labeled data are required is key to successfully deploying these models outside of the clinic. Here we recorded movement data using 6 flexible wearable sensors in 20 individuals with PD over the course of multiple clinical assessments conducted on 1 day and repeated 2 weeks later. Participants performed 13 common tasks, such as walking or typing, and a clinician rated the severity of symptoms (bradykinesia and tremor). We then trained convolutional neural networks and statistical ensembles to detect whether a segment of movement showed signs of bradykinesia or tremor based on data from tasks performed by other individuals. Our results show that a single wearable sensor on the back of the hand is sufficient for detecting bradykinesia and tremor in the upper extremities, whereas using sensors on both sides does not improve performance. Increasing the amount of training data by adding other individuals can lead to improved performance, but repeating assessments with the same individuals-even at different medication states-does not substantially improve detection across days. Our results suggest that PD symptoms can be detected during a variety of activities and are best modeled by a dataset incorporating many individuals.
利用从柔软可穿戴传感器捕获的数据流的机器学习算法有潜力自动检测帕金森病(PD)症状,并向临床医生通报疾病进展情况。然而,这些算法必须使用来自能够识别症状的临床专家的带注释数据进行训练,而收集此类数据成本高昂。了解需要多少传感器以及多少标记数据是在临床环境之外成功部署这些模型的关键。在此,我们在一天内对20名帕金森病患者进行多次临床评估,并在两周后重复进行,期间使用6个灵活的可穿戴传感器记录运动数据。参与者执行了13项常见任务,如行走或打字,一名临床医生对症状(运动迟缓及震颤)的严重程度进行评分。然后,我们训练卷积神经网络和统计集成模型,根据其他个体执行任务的数据来检测一段运动是否显示出运动迟缓或震颤的迹象。我们的结果表明,手背上的单个可穿戴传感器足以检测上肢的运动迟缓和震颤,而双侧使用传感器并不能提高性能。通过添加其他个体来增加训练数据量可提高性能,但对同一批个体重复评估——即使处于不同的药物状态——在不同日期的检测效果也不会有显著改善。我们的结果表明,帕金森病症状可在各种活动期间被检测到,并且最好通过纳入许多个体的数据集来进行建模。