Alharbi Yasser, Al-Mansour Mubarak, Al-Saffar Radi, Garman Abdullah, Alraddadi Abdulrahman
Basic Medical Science, College of Medicine, King Saud Bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Jeddah, SAU.
Adult Medical Oncology, Princess Noorah Oncology Center / College of Medicine, King Abdulaziz Medical City, Ministry of National Guard Health Affairs-Western Region / King Saud Bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Jeddah, SAU.
Cureus. 2020 Feb 24;12(2):e7085. doi: 10.7759/cureus.7085.
Introduction Poor knowledge retention is one reason for medical student attrition in learning and has been a huge concern in medical education. Three-dimensional virtual reality (3D-VR)-based teaching and learning in medical education has been promoted to improve student learning outcomes. This study aimed to determine the effectiveness of 3D-VR in knowledge retention in human anatomy courses as compared to traditional teaching methods among medical students. Methods A convergent mixed methods design was utilized to evaluate learning outcomes in terms of short- and long-term knowledge retention scores among students using 3D-VR and those using traditional models and to describe students' experiences and views of the use of 3D-VR as a teaching and learning tool. Results Male students who used the 3D-VR tool had significantly higher short- and long-term knowledge scores than males who used the traditional methods. Meanwhile, females who used traditional methods showed significantly higher short-term knowledge scores than females who used 3D-VR. Conclusion Medical students described 3D-VR as a learning tool with a great deal to offer for learning human anatomy as compared to traditional methods. Therefore, we recommend adding the use of 3D-VR in the anatomy curriculum. However, several 3D-VR limitations were also identified, which may hinder its utilization for teaching and learning. These concerns must be addressed before 3D-VR tools are considered for implementation in medical education human anatomy courses.
引言
知识保留不佳是医学生学习过程中流失的一个原因,一直是医学教育中备受关注的问题。基于三维虚拟现实(3D-VR)的医学教育教学已得到推广,以提高学生的学习成果。本研究旨在确定与传统教学方法相比,3D-VR在医学生人体解剖学课程知识保留方面的有效性。
方法
采用收敛性混合方法设计,从使用3D-VR的学生和使用传统模型的学生的短期和长期知识保留分数方面评估学习成果,并描述学生对使用3D-VR作为教学工具的体验和看法。
结果
使用3D-VR工具的男学生的短期和长期知识分数显著高于使用传统方法的男学生。同时,使用传统方法的女学生的短期知识分数显著高于使用3D-VR的女学生。
结论
与传统方法相比,医学生将3D-VR描述为一种对学习人体解剖学有很大帮助的学习工具。因此,我们建议在解剖学课程中增加3D-VR的使用。然而,也发现了3D-VR的一些局限性,这可能会阻碍其在教学中的应用。在考虑将3D-VR工具应用于医学教育人体解剖学课程之前,必须解决这些问题。