Department of Environmental Health Science, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, New York, NY, USA.
Independent Consultant, Quito, Ecuador.
J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol. 2020 Jul;30(4):707-720. doi: 10.1038/s41370-020-0231-5. Epub 2020 May 15.
Ecuador presents a unique case study for evaluating personal air pollution exposure in a middle-income country where a clean cooking fuel has been available at low cost for several decades. We measured personal PM exposure, stove use, and participant location during a 48-h monitoring period for 157 rural and peri-urban households in coastal and Andean Ecuador. While nearly all households owned a liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) stove and used it as their primary cooking fuel, one-quarter of households utilized firewood as a secondary fuel and 10% used induction stoves secondary to LPG. Stove use monitoring demonstrated clear within- and across-meal fuel stacking patterns. Firewood-owning participants had higher distributions of 48-h and 10-min PM exposure as compared with primary LPG and induction stove users, and this effect became more pronounced with firewood use during monitoring.Accounting for within-subject clustering, contemporaneous firewood stove use was associated with 101 μg/m higher 10-min PM exposure (95% CI: 94-108 μg/m). LPG and induction cooking events were largely not associated with contemporaneous PM exposure. Our results suggest that firewood use is associated with average and short-term personal air pollution exposure above the WHO interim-I guideline, even when LPG is the primary cooking fuel.
厄瓜多尔为评估中低收入国家的个人空气污染暴露情况提供了一个独特的案例研究,因为该国几十年来一直以低成本提供清洁烹饪燃料。我们在厄瓜多尔沿海和安第斯地区的 157 个农村和城郊家庭中进行了为期 48 小时的监测,测量了个人 PM 暴露、炉灶使用情况和参与者位置。尽管几乎所有家庭都拥有液化石油气 (LPG) 炉灶,并将其作为主要烹饪燃料,但四分之一的家庭将薪柴作为二级燃料,10%的家庭因 LPG 而将感应炉灶作为二级燃料。炉灶使用监测显示出明显的餐内和跨餐燃料堆积模式。与主要使用 LPG 和感应炉灶的用户相比,拥有薪柴的参与者的 48 小时和 10 分钟 PM 暴露分布更高,并且在监测期间使用薪柴时,这种影响变得更加明显。考虑到个体内聚类,同时使用薪柴炉灶与 10 分钟 PM 暴露增加 101μg/m(95%CI:94-108μg/m)有关。LPG 和感应烹饪事件与同期 PM 暴露基本无关。我们的研究结果表明,即使 LPG 是主要烹饪燃料,薪柴的使用也与超过世卫组织临时 I 级指南的平均和短期个人空气污染暴露有关。