Aziz Anbreen, Mahboob Usman, Sethi Ahsan
Dr. Anbreen Aziz, BDS, MHPE. Department of Medical Education, HBS Dental College, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Dr. Usman Mahboob, MBBS, MPH, FHEA, DHPE, Fellow FAIMER. Assistant Professor in Medical Education. Institute of Health Professions Education & Research (IHPER), Khyber Medical University, Peshawar, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2020 Jul-Aug;36(5):1020-1024. doi: 10.12669/pjms.36.5.2267.
To explore problems faced by struggling undergraduate medical students and their impact on student's academics.
A qualitative case study was carried out from March to August 2019. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a purposive sample of sixteen struggling students. The interview questions were validated and then piloted to ensure clarity. All interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. Due to sensitive nature of the data, confidentiality and anonymity was ensured. Thematic analysis was employed to get meaning with in the data set. All authors ensured analytical triangulation by independently analyzing the data before developing consensus on the codes and themes.
Eleven sub-themes under four major themes emerged from the transcripts. Participants were found to be struggling with emotional, academics and family related problems. Psychological distress was caused by factors such as fight with friends, one-sided love, and hard financial times. Time management, lack of attention and commitments at home were few of the other problems. Problems had an impact on students as they were demotivated, lost focus in their studies, could not perform good and few participants even failed in examinations.
Students were struggling more with emotional and family related problems and less with academics related problems. They were impacting student's academics. The study site had a robust mentoring program however, struggling students need timely identification and more dedicated time to help them manage their problems. Stress relieving activities and counselling sessions may frequently be added, and academically underachieved students should also be given extra care, support, and guidance.
探讨学业困难的本科医学生所面临的问题及其对学生学业的影响。
于2019年3月至8月开展了一项定性案例研究。对16名学业困难的学生进行了有目的抽样的半结构式访谈。访谈问题经过验证,然后进行预试验以确保清晰明了。所有访谈均进行了录音并逐字转录。由于数据的敏感性,确保了保密性和匿名性。采用主题分析法从数据集中获取意义。所有作者在就代码和主题达成共识之前,通过独立分析数据确保了分析三角互证。
从访谈记录中出现了四个主要主题下的11个子主题。发现参与者在情感、学业和家庭相关问题上存在困难。心理困扰由与朋友争吵、单恋和经济困难时期等因素引起。时间管理、在家缺乏关注和责任是其他一些问题。这些问题对学生产生了影响,因为他们失去了动力,学习注意力不集中,表现不佳,甚至有少数参与者考试不及格。
学生在情感和家庭相关问题上的困扰更多,而在学业相关问题上的困扰较少。这些问题正在影响学生的学业。研究地点有一个完善的辅导计划,然而,学业困难的学生需要及时识别,并给予更多专门时间来帮助他们解决问题。可能需要经常增加减压活动和咨询课程,对学业成绩不佳的学生也应给予额外的关心、支持和指导。