School of Rehabilitation Science, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada.
Department of Interdisciplinary Science, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 19;17(20):7629. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17207629.
Firefighters appear at an increased risk for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Because of PTSD-related stigma, firefighters may search for information online. The current study evaluated the quality, readability, and completeness of PTSD online resources, and to determine how the online treatment recommendations align with current evidence. Google.ca (Canada) searches were performed using four phrases: 'firefighter PTSD', 'firefighter operational stress', 'PTSD symptoms', and 'PTSD treatment'. The 75 websites identified were assessed using quality criteria for consumer health information (DISCERN), readability and health literacy statistics, content analysis, and a comparison of treatments mentioned to the current best evidence. The average DISCERN score was 43.8 out of 75 (indicating 'fair' quality), with 9 'poor' websites (16-30), 31 'fair' websites (31-45), 26 "good" websites (46-60), and nine excellent websites (61-75). The average grade level required to understand the health-related content was 10.6. The most mentioned content was PTSD symptoms (48/75 websites) and PTSD treatments (60/75 websites). The most frequently mentioned treatments were medications (41/75 websites) and cognitive behavioural therapy (40/75 websites). Cognitive behavioural therapy is supported by strong evidence, but evidence for medications appears inconsistent in current systematic reviews. Online PTSD resources exist for firefighters, but the information is challenging to read and lacks evidence-based treatment recommendations.
消防员患创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的风险增加。由于 PTSD 相关的污名,消防员可能会在网上搜索信息。本研究评估了 PTSD 在线资源的质量、可读性和完整性,并确定在线治疗建议与当前证据的一致性。使用四个短语在 Google.ca(加拿大)上进行了搜索:“消防员 PTSD”、“消防员作业压力”、“PTSD 症状”和“PTSD 治疗”。确定了 75 个网站,并使用消费者健康信息(DISCERN)质量标准、可读性和健康素养统计数据、内容分析以及与当前最佳证据相比的治疗方法比较对其进行了评估。平均 DISCERN 得分为 75 分中的 43.8 分(表示“中等”质量),其中 9 个网站较差(16-30 分),31 个网站中等(31-45 分),26 个网站良好(46-60 分),9 个网站优秀(61-75 分)。理解与健康相关内容所需的平均年级水平为 10.6。提到最多的内容是 PTSD 症状(48/75 个网站)和 PTSD 治疗(60/75 个网站)。最常提到的治疗方法是药物治疗(41/75 个网站)和认知行为疗法(40/75 个网站)。认知行为疗法有强有力的证据支持,但当前系统评价中的药物治疗证据似乎不一致。有针对消防员的 PTSD 在线资源,但信息难以阅读,并且缺乏基于证据的治疗建议。