Banks Laura, Randhawa Varinder K, Caterini Jessica, Colella Tracey J F, Dhanvantari Savita, McMurtry Sean, Connelly Kim A, Robinson Lisa, Anand Sonia S, Ouzounian Maral, Zieroth Shelley, Mak Susanna, Straus Sharon, Graham Michelle M
Cardiovascular Prevention and Rehabilitation Program, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Ontario Tech University, Ontario, Canada.
CJC Open. 2020 Jul 2;2(6):522-529. doi: 10.1016/j.cjco.2020.06.016. eCollection 2020 Nov.
A previous review of sex, gender, and equity within cardiovascular (CV) medicine, surgery, and science in Canada has revealed parity during medical and graduate school training. The purpose of this study was to explore sex and gendered experiences within the Canadian CV landscape, and their impact on career training and progression.
An environmental scan was conducted of the Canadian CV landscape, which included an equity survey using Qualtrics software.
The environmental scan revealed that women remain underrepresented within CV training programs as trainees (12%-30%), program directors (33%), in leadership roles at the divisional level (21%), and in other professional or career-related activities (< 30%). Our analysis also showed improvements of career engagement at these levels of women at over time. The thematic analysis of the equity survey responses (n = 71 respondents; 83% female; 9.7% response rate among female Canadian Cardiovascular Society members) identified the following themes reported within the socio-ecological framework: desire to report inequities vs staying the course (individual level); desire for social support and mentorship and challenges of dual responsibilities (interpersonal level); concerns over exclusionary cliques and desire for respect and opportunity (organizational level); and increasing awareness and actions to overcome institutional barriers and accountability (societal level).
Although women face challenges and remain underrepresented in CV medicine, surgery, and science, this study highlights potential opportunities for improving access of female medical, surgical, and research trainees and professionals to specialized cardiovascular training, career advancement, leadership, and research.
先前一项对加拿大心血管医学、外科手术及科学领域中的性别与公平性的综述显示,在医学及研究生阶段的培训中存在性别平等。本研究的目的是探讨加拿大心血管领域中的性别经历,及其对职业培训与发展的影响。
对加拿大心血管领域进行了一次环境扫描,其中包括使用Qualtrics软件进行的公平性调查。
环境扫描显示,在心血管培训项目中,女性作为学员(12%-30%)、项目主任(33%)、部门层面的领导角色(21%)以及其他专业或与职业相关活动中的代表人数仍然不足(<30%)。我们的分析还表明,随着时间的推移,这些层面的女性职业参与度有所提高。对公平性调查回复(n = 71名受访者;83%为女性;加拿大心血管学会女性成员的回复率为9.7%)的主题分析确定了社会生态框架内报告的以下主题:报告不平等现象的意愿与坚持现状(个人层面);对社会支持和指导的渴望以及双重责任带来的挑战(人际层面);对排他性小团体的担忧以及对尊重和机会的渴望(组织层面);以及提高认识和采取行动克服制度障碍和问责制(社会层面)。
尽管女性在心血管医学、外科手术及科学领域面临挑战且代表性仍然不足,但本研究突出了改善女性医学、外科手术及研究学员和专业人员获得专业心血管培训、职业晋升、领导力及研究机会的潜在可能性。