Human Performance and Sports Science Laboratory, Faculty of Sport Sciences, University of Murcia, Murcia, Spain.
J Sports Sci. 2021 Jun;39(12):1312-1319. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2020.1868090. Epub 2020 Dec 30.
This study aimed to analyse the (i) concurrent validity, (ii) inter-unit reliability, and (iii) biological variability of a low-cost device called Pocket radar. Eleven men recreational soccer players performed 6 kicks to a soccer ball, whereas 13 men recreational tennis players conducted 10 shots to a tennis ball. All executions were simultaneously measured by two Pocket units and the Stalker radar (reference criterion). The within-subject variation among the executions was used for the biological variability analysis. The level of agreement and magnitude of errors included the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Pearson's correlation coefficient (r), bias, and the smallest detectable change (SDC). A good agreement (ICC ≥ 0.98, r ≥ 0.98) and very low magnitude of error (SDC ≤ 7.70 km·h, bias ≤ 3.19 km·h) were found between both Pocket units and the Stalker, in soccer and tennis. Inter-unit analysis found limited technical errors (SDC ≤ 5.49 km·h, bias ≤ -0.93 km·h) and nearly perfect agreement (ICC = 0.99, r ≥ 0.98) in both sessions. These technical errors were lower than the variations due to the biological variability, in soccer (SDC = 2.47 km·h vs. SDC ≥ 8.6 km·h) and tennis (SDC = 5.49 km·h vs. SDC ≥ 21.95 km·h). These findings suggest the Pocket radar as a valid and highly sensitive tool for BV measurement.
本研究旨在分析一种名为 Pocket radar 的低成本设备的:(i) 同时效度,(ii) 单元间可靠性,以及 (iii) 生物学变异性。11 名男性业余足球运动员向足球踢了 6 次,而 13 名男性业余网球运动员向网球打了 10 次。所有的动作都同时被两个 Pocket 单元和 Stalker 雷达(参考标准)进行测量。生物变异性分析中使用了动作之间的个体内差异。一致性水平和误差幅度包括组内相关系数 (ICC)、皮尔逊相关系数 (r)、偏差和最小可检测变化 (SDC)。在足球和网球中,两个 Pocket 单元与 Stalker 之间都具有很好的一致性 (ICC≥0.98,r≥0.98) 和非常低的误差幅度 (SDC≤7.70km·h,bias≤3.19km·h)。单元间分析发现,两个测试中都存在有限的技术误差 (SDC≤5.49km·h,bias≤-0.93km·h),且几乎具有完美的一致性 (ICC=0.99,r≥0.98)。这些技术误差低于足球 (SDC=2.47km·h 与 SDC≥8.6km·h) 和网球 (SDC=5.49km·h 与 SDC≥21.95km·h) 中由于生物学变异性引起的变化。这些结果表明 Pocket radar 是一种用于测量 BV 的有效且高度敏感的工具。