Vickery Michelle, van Teijlingen Edwin, Hundley Vanora, Smith Gary B, Way Susan, Westwood Greta
Department of Midwifery & Health Sciences, Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, Bournemouth University, Bournemouth, United Kingdom.
Florence Nightingale Foundation, London, United Kingdom.
Eur J Midwifery. 2020 Sep 17;4:36. doi: 10.18332/ejm/126625. eCollection 2020.
There are many mobile telephone apps to help women self-monitor aspects of pregnancy and maternal health. This literature review aims to understand midwives' perspectives on women self-monitoring their pregnancy using eHealth and mHealth, and establish gaps in research.
MEDLINE, PubMed, Scopus, CINAHL and PsycINFO were systematically searched on midwifery, eHealth/mHealth and perspectives. Qualitative, quantitative and mixed-methods studies published in English were considered for inclusion in the review, without geographical limitations. Relevant articles were critically appraised and narrative synthesis was conducted.
Twelve relevant papers covering midwives' perspectives of the use of eHealth and mHealth by pregnant women were obtained for inclusion in this review. Seven of these publications focused on midwives' views of eHealth, and five on their perspectives of mHealth interventions. The studies included demonstrate that midwives generally hold ambivalent views towards the use of eHealth and mHealth technologies in antenatal care. Often, midwives acknowledged the potential benefits of such technologies, such as their ability to modernise antenatal care and to help women make more informed decisions about their pregnancy. However, midwives were quick to point out the risks and limitations of these, such as the accuracy of conveyed information, and negative impacts on the patient-professional relationship.
Post-COVID-19, where technology is continuously developing, there is a compelling need for studies that investigate the role of eHealth and mHealth in self-monitoring pregnancy, and the consequences this has for pregnant women, health professionals and organisations, as well as midwifery curricula.
有许多移动电话应用程序可帮助女性自我监测孕期及孕产妇健康的各个方面。本系统综述旨在了解助产士对于女性使用电子健康和移动健康技术自我监测孕期的看法,并找出研究中的差距。
对MEDLINE、PubMed、Scopus、CINAHL和PsycINFO数据库进行系统检索,检索词为助产、电子健康/移动健康和看法。纳入综述的研究需为以英文发表的定性、定量及混合方法研究,无地域限制。对相关文章进行严格评估并进行叙述性综合分析。
共获得12篇相关论文,纳入本综述,内容涉及助产士对孕妇使用电子健康和移动健康技术的看法。其中7篇出版物聚焦于助产士对电子健康的看法,5篇聚焦于他们对移动健康干预措施的看法。纳入的研究表明,助产士对于在产前护理中使用电子健康和移动健康技术普遍持矛盾态度。助产士通常认可这些技术的潜在益处,比如能够使产前护理现代化,帮助女性在孕期做出更明智的决定。然而,助产士也很快指出了这些技术的风险和局限性,比如所传达信息的准确性,以及对医患关系的负面影响。
在新冠疫情之后,技术不断发展,迫切需要开展研究,调查电子健康和移动健康在自我监测孕期中的作用,以及这对孕妇、卫生专业人员和机构,乃至助产士课程的影响。