Pant Puspa Raj, Mytton Julie, Dharel Milan Raj, Dangi Amrit, Rai Writu Bhatta, Joshi Sunil Kumar
Faculty of Health and Applied Sciences, University of the West of England Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1NU, UK.
Bristol Medical School, Centre for Academic Child Health, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1NU, UK.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2021 Apr 14;19(1):65. doi: 10.1186/s12961-021-00686-1.
Injuries, the cause of an estimated 4.5 million deaths annually and many more disabilities worldwide each year, are the predictable outcome of particular circumstances. One of the most effective ways to prevent injuries is through policy and legislation. The aim of this research study was to identify and critically review all policy and legislation in Nepal that had the potential to prevent injuries.
We identified legislation and policy that met inclusion criteria through a stakeholder meeting, networks and contacts, and websites and electronic resources. Each included document was critically reviewed to identify areas of strength and opportunities for improvement. We compared the included documents against WHO's recommendations of known effective interventions.
Sixty-two documents met the inclusion criteria for this review. Of these, 24 (38.7%) were exclusively related to road injuries, 11 (17.7%) to occupational injuries, 6 (9.7%) to injuries in the home and 5 (8.1%) to injuries at school; 30 (48.4%) documents included text related to the first response to injuries. Of 127 strategic recommendations by WHO that provided an area for policy or legislative focus, 21 (16.5%) were considered adequately met by Nepali policy and legislation, 43 (33.9%) were considered partially met and 63 (49.6%) were not met.
We drew five conclusions from this critical policy review, which we have related to recommendations as follows: widening the scope of legislation and policy for injury prevention to emphasize injuries occurring at home or school; addressing the causes of injuries and promoting proven preventive measures; greater clarity on both individual and institutional roles and responsibilities; trustworthy data and quality evidence to inform decision-making; and financial investment and capacity-strengthening for injury prevention and first response. The current system of federal governance in Nepal has potential for strengthening injury prevention and first response at the central, provincial and local levels.
伤害是特定情况可预测的结果,在全球范围内,伤害每年估计导致450万人死亡,造成更多人残疾。预防伤害最有效的方法之一是通过政策和立法。本研究的目的是识别并严格审查尼泊尔所有有可能预防伤害的政策和立法。
我们通过利益相关者会议、网络和联系人以及网站和电子资源,识别符合纳入标准的立法和政策。对每份纳入文件进行严格审查,以确定其优势领域和改进机会。我们将纳入文件与世界卫生组织关于已知有效干预措施的建议进行比较。
62份文件符合本次审查的纳入标准。其中,24份(38.7%)专门涉及道路伤害,11份(17.7%)涉及职业伤害,6份(9.7%)涉及家庭伤害,5份(8.1%)涉及学校伤害;有30份(48.4%)文件包含与伤害急救相关的内容。在世界卫生组织提出的127项提供政策或立法重点领域的战略建议中,尼泊尔的政策和立法认为21项(16.5%)得到了充分满足,43项(33.9%)部分得到满足,63项(49.6%)未得到满足。
我们从这次严格的政策审查中得出了五条结论,并将其与建议相关联如下:扩大预防伤害的立法和政策范围,以强调发生在家庭或学校的伤害;解决伤害原因并推广经证实的预防措施;更明确个人和机构的角色及责任;提供可靠数据和高质量证据以指导决策;以及为预防伤害和急救进行财政投资和能力建设。尼泊尔目前的联邦治理体系有潜力加强中央政府、省级政府和地方政府在预防伤害和急救方面的工作。