Rueckel Johannes, Sperl Jonathan I, Kaestle Sophia, Hoppe Boj F, Fink Nicola, Rudolph Jan, Schwarze Vincent, Geyer Thomas, Strobl Frederik F, Ricke Jens, Ingrisch Michael, Sabel Bastian O
Department of Radiology, University Hospital, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany.
Siemens Healthineers AG, Erlangen, Germany.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2021 Jun;11(6):2486-2498. doi: 10.21037/qims-20-1037.
Radiology reporting of emergency whole-body computed tomography (CT) scans is time-critical and therefore involves a significant risk of pathology under-detection. We hypothesize a relevant number of initially missed secondary thoracic findings that would have been detected by an artificial intelligence (AI) software platform including several pathology-specific AI algorithms.
This retrospective proof-of-concept-study consecutively included 105 shock-room whole-body CT scans. Image data was analyzed by platform-bundled AI-algorithms, findings were reviewed by radiology experts and compared with the original radiologist's reports. We focused on secondary thoracic findings, such as cardiomegaly, coronary artery plaques, lung lesions, aortic aneurysms and vertebral fractures.
We identified a relevant number of initially missed findings, with their quantification based on 105 analyzed CT scans as follows: up to 25 patients (23.8%) with cardiomegaly or borderline heart size, 17 patients (16.2%) with coronary plaques, 34 patients (32.4%) with aortic ectasia, 2 patients (1.9%) with lung lesions classified as "recommended to control" and 13 initially missed vertebral fractures (two with an acute traumatic origin). A high number of false positive or non-relevant AI-based findings remain problematic especially regarding lung lesions and vertebral fractures.
We consider AI to be a promising approach to reduce the number of missed findings in clinical settings with a necessary time-critical radiological reporting. Nevertheless, algorithm improvement is necessary focusing on a reduction of "false positive" findings and on algorithm features assessing the finding relevance, e.g., fracture age or lung lesion malignancy.
急诊全身计算机断层扫描(CT)的放射学报告对时间要求很高,因此存在漏诊病变的重大风险。我们推测,人工智能(AI)软件平台(包括几种针对特定病变的AI算法)能够检测出相当数量最初被漏诊的继发性胸部病变。
这项回顾性概念验证研究连续纳入了105例急诊室全身CT扫描。图像数据由平台捆绑的AI算法进行分析,结果由放射学专家进行审查,并与原放射科医生的报告进行比较。我们重点关注继发性胸部病变,如心脏扩大、冠状动脉斑块、肺部病变、主动脉瘤和椎体骨折。
我们发现了相当数量最初被漏诊的病变,基于105例分析的CT扫描对其进行量化如下:多达25例患者(23.8%)有心脏扩大或临界心脏大小,17例患者(16.2%)有冠状动脉斑块,34例患者(32.4%)有主动脉扩张,2例患者(1.9%)有被归类为“建议复查”的肺部病变,以及13例最初被漏诊的椎体骨折(其中两例为急性创伤性骨折)。大量基于AI的假阳性或无关结果仍然存在问题,尤其是在肺部病变和椎体骨折方面。
我们认为,在对时间要求严格的临床放射学报告中,AI是一种有前景的方法,可减少漏诊病变的数量。然而,有必要改进算法,重点是减少“假阳性”结果,并改进评估结果相关性的算法功能,例如骨折时间或肺部病变的恶性程度。