Slater Justin J, Brown Patrick E, Rosenthal Jeffrey S, Mateu Jorge
Department of Statistical Sciences, University of Toronto, Canada.
Centre for Global Health Research, St. Michael's Hospital, Canada.
Spat Stat. 2022 Jun;49:100540. doi: 10.1016/j.spasta.2021.100540. Epub 2021 Sep 28.
Spatial dependence is usually introduced into spatial models using some measure of physical proximity. When analysing COVID-19 case counts, this makes sense as regions that are close together are more likely to have more people moving between them, spreading the disease. However, using the actual number of trips between each region may explain COVID-19 case counts better than physical proximity. In this paper, we investigate the efficacy of using telecommunications-derived mobility data to induce spatial dependence in spatial models applied to two Spanish communities' COVID-19 case counts. We do this by extending Besag York Mollié (BYM) models to include both a physical adjacency effect, alongside a mobility effect. The mobility effect is given a Gaussian Markov random field prior, with the number of trips between regions as edge weights. We leverage modern parametrizations of BYM models to conclude that the number of people moving between regions better explains variation in COVID-19 case counts than physical proximity data. We suggest that this data should be used in conjunction with physical proximity data when developing spatial models for COVID-19 case counts.
空间依赖性通常通过某种物理邻近性度量引入到空间模型中。在分析新冠疫情病例数时,这是合理的,因为距离较近的地区之间更有可能有更多人员往来,从而传播疾病。然而,使用各地区之间的实际出行次数可能比物理邻近性更能解释新冠疫情病例数。在本文中,我们研究了利用电信衍生的移动性数据在应用于两个西班牙社区新冠疫情病例数的空间模型中引入空间依赖性的效果。我们通过扩展贝萨格-约克-莫利(BYM)模型来实现这一点,使其既包括物理邻接效应,又包括移动性效应。移动性效应采用高斯马尔可夫随机场先验分布,各地区之间的出行次数作为边权重。我们利用BYM模型的现代参数化方法得出结论,地区之间的人员流动数量比物理邻近性数据更能解释新冠疫情病例数的变化。我们建议,在为新冠疫情病例数建立空间模型时,应将这些数据与物理邻近性数据结合使用。