de Sousa Geovan Menezes, Tavares Vagner Deuel de Oliveira, de Meiroz Grilo Maria Lara Porpino, Coelho Monique Leite Galvão, de Lima-Araújo Geissy Lainny, Schuch Felipe Barreto, Galvão-Coelho Nicole Leite
Laboratory of Hormone Measurement, Department of Physiology and Behaviour, Federal University of Rio Grande Do Norte, Natal, Brazil.
Graduate Program in Psychobiology and Department of Physiology and Behaviour, Federal University of Rio Grande Do Norte, Natal, Brazil.
Front Psychol. 2021 Sep 21;12:703838. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.703838. eCollection 2021.
Mental health burden has been massively reported during the COVID-19 pandemic period. Aiming to summarise these data, we present a meta-review of meta-analyses that evaluated the impact of COVID-19 pandemic on anxiety, depressive and stress symptoms, psychological distress, post-traumatic stress disorder/symptoms (PTSD), and sleep disturbance, reporting its prevalence on general public (GP) and health care workers (HCW). A search was performed in the PubMed, EMBASE, and the Web of Science. Sleep disturbances, psychological distress, stress, and burnout were grouped as "Psychophysiological stress," and anxiety, depression, and PTSD were grouped as "Psychopathology." A random-effects model, calculating the pooled prevalence together with 95% confidence interval was performed for each domain. Subgroup analyses were performed for each population type (GP and HCW) and for each mental health outcome. For anxiety and depression, subgroup analysis for population type was performed. Heterogeneity is reported as . Publication bias was assessed through visual inspection of the funnel plot, and further tested by Egger's test and trim and fill analyses. A total of 18 meta-analyses were included. The prevalence of psychophysiological stress was 31.99% (CI: 26.88-37.58, = 99.9%). HCW showed a higher prevalence (37.74%, CI: 33.26-42.45, = 99.7%) than the GP (20.67%, 15.07-27.66, = 99.9%). The overall prevalence of insomnia, psychological distress, and stress were, respectively, 32.34% (CI: 25.65-39.84), 28.25% (CI: 18.12-41.20), and 36% (CI: 29.31-43.54). Psychopathology was present at 26.45% (CI: 24.22-28.79, = 99.9%) of the sample, with similar estimates for population (HCW 26.14%, CI: 23.37-29.12, = 99.9%; GP: 26.99%, CI: 23.41-30.9, = 99.9%). The prevalence of anxiety, depression, and PTSD was 27.77% (CI: 24.47-31.32), 26.93% (CI: 23.92-30.17), and 20% (CI: 15.54-24.37), respectively. Similar proportions between populations were found for anxiety (HCW = 27.5%, CI: 23.78-31.55; GP = 28.33%, CI: 22.1-35.5) and depression (HCW = 27.05%, CI: 23.14-31.36; GP = 26.7%, CI: 22.32-31.59). Asymmetry in the funnel plot was found, and a slight increase in the estimate of overall psychopathology (29.08%, CI: 26.42-31.89) was found after the trim and fill analysis. The prevalence of mental health problems ranged from 20 to 36%. HCW presented a higher prevalence of psychophysiological stress than the general population. https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?RecordID=252221, identifier: CRD42021252221.
在新冠疫情期间,心理健康负担的相关报道大量涌现。为总结这些数据,我们对多项荟萃分析进行了综合回顾,这些分析评估了新冠疫情对焦虑、抑郁和压力症状、心理困扰、创伤后应激障碍/症状(PTSD)以及睡眠障碍的影响,并报告了其在普通公众(GP)和医护人员(HCW)中的患病率。我们在PubMed、EMBASE和科学网进行了检索。睡眠障碍、心理困扰、压力和职业倦怠被归为“心理生理应激”,焦虑、抑郁和PTSD被归为“精神病理学”。对每个领域都采用随机效应模型计算合并患病率及95%置信区间。对每种人群类型(GP和HCW)以及每种心理健康结果进行了亚组分析。对于焦虑和抑郁,按人群类型进行了亚组分析。异质性报告为 。通过漏斗图的直观检查评估发表偏倚,并进一步通过Egger检验和修剪填充分析进行检验。共纳入18项荟萃分析。心理生理应激的患病率为31.99%(CI:26.88 - 37.58, = 99.9%)。医护人员的患病率(37.74%,CI:33.26 - 42.45, = 99.7%)高于普通公众(20.67%,15.07 - 27.66, = 99.9%)。失眠、心理困扰和压力的总体患病率分别为32.34%(CI:25.65 - 39.84)、28.25%(CI:18.12 - 41.20)和36%(CI:29.31 - 43.54)。精神病理学在样本中的患病率为26.45%(CI:24.22 - 28.79, = 99.9%),人群中的估计值相似(医护人员为26.14%,CI:23.37 - 29.12, = 99.9%;普通公众为26.99%,CI:23.41 - 30.9, = 99.9%)。焦虑、抑郁和PTSD的患病率分别为27.77%(CI:24.47 - 31.32)、26.93%(CI:23.92 - 30.17)和20%(CI:15.54 - 24.37)。在焦虑(医护人员 = 27.5%,CI:23.78 - 31.55;普通公众 = 28.33%,CI:22.1 - 35.5)和抑郁(医护人员 = 27.05%,CI:23.14 - 31.36;普通公众 = 26.7%,CI:22.32 - 31.59)方面,人群间比例相似。在漏斗图中发现了不对称性,修剪填充分析后发现总体精神病理学估计值略有增加(29.08%,CI:26.42 - 31.89)。心理健康问题的患病率在20%至36%之间。医护人员的心理生理应激患病率高于普通人群。https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/display_record.php?RecordID=252221,标识符:CRD42021252221