Phillips C I, Gore S M, Gunn P M
Br J Ophthalmol. 1978 May;62(5):296-301. doi: 10.1136/bjo.62.5.296.
In a 1-day, 1-dose, double-masked, randomised trial, with each of 12 patients acting as his/her own control, atenolol drops 4% (a selective beta1-adrenergic blocker) produced a significantly greater fall in ocular tension measured by applanation than did adrenaline drops 1% (P is less than 0.01 Wilcoxon matched pairs signed ranks test). The mean differences, which favoured atenolol, between the falls in pressure produced by these 2 drugs at 1.5 hours, 3.5 hours, 5.5 hours, and 7 hours after instillation of the drops was 2.1, 4.6, 4.0, and 3.6 mmHg, respectively. Long-term studies would be required before any conclusion was justified about the relative merits of these 2 drugs in the treatment of glaucoma. There was no significant difference between the ocular hypotensive effects of atenolol-then-adrenaline and adrenaline-then-atenolol. It was disappointing that the expected adjuvant effect of atenolol's preceding adrenaline was not found-rather the reverse. Atenolol alone, however, was significantly better than atenolol-then-adrenaline (P is less than 0.02 Wilcoxon matched pairs signed ranks test), and there was also some indication that it was superior to adrenaline-then-atenolol. The response to adrenaline did not differ markedly from the response to the combination in either order.
在一项为期1天、单剂量、双盲、随机试验中,12名患者各自作为自身对照,4%的阿替洛尔滴眼液(一种选择性β1肾上腺素能阻滞剂)通过压平眼压计测量得出的眼压下降幅度显著大于1%的肾上腺素滴眼液(P<0.01,Wilcoxon配对符号秩检验)。滴入滴眼液后1.5小时、3.5小时、5.5小时和7小时,这两种药物引起的眼压下降幅度相比,阿替洛尔更优,平均差值分别为2.1、4.6、4.0和3.6 mmHg。在对这两种药物治疗青光眼的相对优势得出任何合理结论之前,还需要进行长期研究。先使用阿替洛尔后使用肾上腺素与先使用肾上腺素后使用阿替洛尔的降眼压效果之间无显著差异。令人失望的是,未发现阿替洛尔先于肾上腺素使用时预期的佐剂效应——情况恰恰相反。然而,单独使用阿替洛尔显著优于先使用阿替洛尔后使用肾上腺素(P<0.02,Wilcoxon配对符号秩检验),并且也有一些迹象表明它优于先使用肾上腺素后使用阿替洛尔。无论顺序如何,对肾上腺素的反应与对联合用药的反应没有明显差异。