Department of Communication Science and Disorders, University of Pittsburgh, PA.
Geriatric Research Education and Clinical Center, VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System, PA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2022 Mar 8;65(3):906-922. doi: 10.1044/2021_JSLHR-21-00344. Epub 2022 Feb 8.
Language abilities have long been thought to be weaker in adults who stutter (AWS) compared to adults who do not stutter (AWNS). However, it is unknown whether modality affects language performance by AWS in time pressure situations. This study aimed to examine lexical access and retrieval abilities of AWS in oral and typed modes.
Fifteen AWS and 15 well-matched AWNS completed computer-administered letter fluency tasks. Adults were asked to orally produce words that began with one of two letter targets and type words that began with one of two alternate letters. Conditions were counterbalanced across participants.
Generalized linear mixed-effects models were evaluated to determine the effects of group (AWS/AWNS), mode (oral/typed), and expressive vocabulary on letter fluency performance. Group predicted letter fluency such that AWS generated fewer items on both the oral and typed letter fluency tasks. Mode did not impact letter fluency results. Expressive Vocabulary Test scores predicted letter fluency similarly in both AWS and AWNS.
AWS were not penalized by oral task demands. AWS generated fewer items on the letter fluency tasks regardless of response mode, suggesting that they have weaker lexical access abilities. Furthermore, better expressive vocabulary skills were associated with better letter fluency performance in both groups.
长期以来,人们一直认为口吃成年人(AWS)的语言能力比不口吃成年人(AWNS)弱。然而,在时间压力下,模式是否会影响 AWS 的语言表现还不得而知。本研究旨在检查 AWS 在口头和打字模式下的词汇检索能力。
15 名 AWS 和 15 名匹配良好的 AWNS 完成了计算机管理的字母流畅性任务。要求成年人用两个字母目标中的一个开始口头说出单词,并输入以两个替代字母中的一个开始的单词。条件在参与者之间平衡。
评估广义线性混合效应模型以确定组(AWS/AWNS)、模式(口头/打字)和表达词汇对字母流畅性表现的影响。组预测了字母流畅性,即 AWS 在口头和打字字母流畅性任务中生成的项目都较少。模式对字母流畅性结果没有影响。在 AWS 和 AWNS 中,表达词汇测试分数对字母流畅性的预测相似。
AWS 不受口头任务需求的惩罚。AWS 在字母流畅性任务中生成的项目较少,无论响应模式如何,这表明他们的词汇检索能力较弱。此外,更好的表达词汇技能与两组的更好的字母流畅性表现相关。