Jackson Devlon N, Sehgal Neil, Baur Cynthia
Department of Behavioral and Community Health, Center for Health Literacy, Center for Health Equity, School of Public Health, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, United States.
Department of Behavioral and Community Health, Center for Health Literacy, School of Public Health, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2022 Mar 9;6(3):e26764. doi: 10.2196/26764.
Participatory research methodologies can provide insight into the use of mobile health (mHealth) apps, cultural preferences and needs, and health literacy issues for racial and ethnic groups, such as African Americans and Hispanics who experience health disparities.
This methodological paper aims to describe a 1-year multi-method participatory research process that directly engaged English-speaking African American and bilingual or Spanish-speaking Hispanic adults in designing a prevention-focused, personalized mHealth, information-seeking smartphone app. We report design team participants' experiences with the methods to show why our approach is valuable in producing apps that are more aligned with their needs.
Three design sessions were conducted to inform the iteration of a prevention-focused, personalized mHealth, information-seeking app. The research team led sessions with 2 community member design teams. Design team participants described their goals, motives, and interests regarding prevention information using different approaches, such as collage and card sorting (design session 1), interaction with the app prototype (design session 2), and rating of cultural appropriateness strategies (design session 3).
Each design team had 5 to 6 participants: 2 to 3 male participants and 3 female participants aged between 30 and 76 years. Design team participants shared their likes and dislikes about the sessions and the overall experience of the design sessions. Both African American and Hispanic teams reported positive participation experience. The primary reasons included the opportunity for their views to be heard, collectively working together in the design process, having their apprehension about mHealth reduced, and an opportunity to increase their knowledge of how they could manage their health through mHealth. The feedback from each session informed the following design sessions and a community-engaged process. In addition, the specific findings for each design session informed the design of the app for both communities.
This multi-method participatory research process revealed 4 key lessons learned and recommendations for future research in mHealth app design for African Americans and Hispanics. Lesson 1-community partnerships are key because they provide the chain of trust that helps African American and Hispanic participants feel comfortable participating in app research. Lesson 2-community-based participatory research principles continue to yield promising results to engage these populations in mHealth research. Lesson 3-interactive design sessions uncover participants' needs and development opportunities for mHealth tools. Lesson 4-multiple design sessions with different methods provide an in-depth understanding of participants' mHealth preferences and needs. Future developers should consider these methods and lessons to ensure health apps in the marketplace contribute to eliminating health disparities and achieving health equity.
参与式研究方法可以深入了解移动健康(mHealth)应用程序的使用情况、文化偏好和需求,以及种族和族裔群体(如经历健康差距的非裔美国人和西班牙裔)的健康素养问题。
本方法学论文旨在描述一个为期一年的多方法参与式研究过程,该过程直接让说英语的非裔美国成年人以及双语或说西班牙语的西班牙裔成年人参与设计一款以预防为重点、个性化的移动健康信息搜索智能手机应用程序。我们报告设计团队参与者对这些方法的体验,以展示我们的方法为何在开发更符合他们需求的应用程序方面具有价值。
进行了三次设计会议,为一款以预防为重点、个性化的移动健康信息搜索应用程序的迭代提供信息。研究团队与两个社区成员设计团队共同主持会议。设计团队参与者使用不同方法(如拼贴和卡片分类(设计会议1)、与应用程序原型互动(设计会议2)以及对文化适宜性策略进行评分(设计会议3))描述了他们关于预防信息的目标、动机和兴趣。
每个设计团队有5至6名参与者:2至3名男性参与者和3名女性参与者,年龄在30至76岁之间。设计团队参与者分享了他们对会议以及设计会议总体体验的喜欢和不喜欢之处。非裔美国人和西班牙裔团队都报告了积极的参与体验。主要原因包括有机会表达自己的观点、在设计过程中共同协作、减少对移动健康的担忧,以及有机会增加关于如何通过移动健康管理自身健康的知识。每次会议的反馈为后续设计会议和社区参与过程提供了参考。此外,每次设计会议的具体结果为两个社区的应用程序设计提供了依据。
这个多方法参与式研究过程揭示了4条关键经验教训以及对未来针对非裔美国人和西班牙裔的移动健康应用程序设计研究的建议。经验教训1——社区伙伴关系至关重要,因为它们提供了信任链条,有助于非裔美国人和西班牙裔参与者放心地参与应用程序研究。经验教训2——基于社区的参与式研究原则在让这些人群参与移动健康研究方面继续产生了有前景的结果。经验教训3——交互式设计会议揭示了参与者对移动健康工具的需求和发展机会。经验教训4——采用不同方法进行多次设计会议能够深入了解参与者对移动健康的偏好和需求。未来的开发者应考虑这些方法和经验教训,以确保市场上的健康应用程序有助于消除健康差距并实现健康公平。