Mayer Rulon, Simone Charles B, Turkbey Baris, Choyke Peter
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
OncoScore, Garrett Park, MD, USA.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2022 Mar;12(3):1859-1870. doi: 10.21037/qims-21-761.
Radiologists currently subjectively examine multi-parametric magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to detect possible clinically significant lesions using the Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System (PI-RADS) protocol. The assessment of imaging, however, relies on the experience and judgement of radiologists creating opportunity for inter-reader variability. Quantitative metrics, such as z-score and signal to clutter ratio (SCR), are therefore needed.
Multi-parametric MRI (T1, T2, diffusion, dynamic contrast-enhanced images) were resampled, rescaled, translated, and stitched to form spatially registered multi-parametric cubes for patients undergoing radical prostatectomy. Multi-parametric signatures that characterize prostate tumors were inserted into z-score and SCR. The multispectral covariance matrix was computed for the outlined normal prostate. The z-score from each MRI image was computed and summed. To reduce noise in the covariance matrix, following matrix decomposition, the noisy eigenvectors were removed. Also, regularization and modified regularization was applied to the covariance matrix by minimizing the discrimination score. The filtered and regularized covariance matrices were inserted into the SCR calculation. The z-score and SCR were quantitatively compared to Gleason scores from clinical pathology assessment of the histology of sectioned wholemount prostates.
Twenty-six consecutive patients were enrolled in this retrospective study. Median patient age was 60 years (range, 49 to 75 years), median prostate-specific antigen (PSA) was 5.8 ng/mL (range, 2.3 to 23.7 ng/mL), and median Gleason score was 7 (range, 6 to 9). A linear fit of the summed z-score against Gleason score found a correlation of R=0.48 and a P value of 0.015. A linear fit of the SCR from regularizing covariance matrix against Gleason score found a correlation of R=0.39 and a P value of 0.058. The SCR employing the modified regularizing covariance matrix against Gleason score found a correlation of R=0.52 and a P value of 0.007. A linear fit of the SCR from filtering out 3 and 4 eigenvectors from the covariance matrix against Gleason score found correlations of R=0.50 and 0.44, respectively, and P values of 0.011 and 0.027, respectively.
Z-score and SCR using filtered and regularized covariance matrices derived from spatially registered multi-parametric MRI correlates with Gleason score with highly significant P values.
放射科医生目前根据前列腺影像报告和数据系统(PI-RADS)协议主观检查多参数磁共振成像(MRI),以检测可能具有临床意义的病变。然而,影像评估依赖于放射科医生的经验和判断,这就产生了阅片者之间的差异。因此,需要诸如z分数和信号杂波比(SCR)等定量指标。
对接受根治性前列腺切除术患者的多参数MRI(T1、T2、扩散加权成像、动态对比增强成像)进行重采样、重新缩放、平移和拼接,以形成空间配准的多参数立方体。将表征前列腺肿瘤的多参数特征插入z分数和SCR中。计算勾勒出的正常前列腺的多光谱协方差矩阵。计算并汇总每个MRI图像的z分数。为了减少协方差矩阵中的噪声,在矩阵分解后,去除有噪声的特征向量。此外,通过最小化判别分数,对协方差矩阵应用正则化和改进的正则化。将经过滤波和正则化的协方差矩阵插入SCR计算中。将z分数和SCR与经切片全前列腺组织学临床病理评估得到的Gleason评分进行定量比较。
本回顾性研究纳入了26例连续患者。患者中位年龄为60岁(范围49至75岁),中位前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)为5.8 ng/mL(范围2.3至23.7 ng/mL),中位Gleason评分为7分(范围6至9)。汇总z分数与Gleason评分的线性拟合发现相关系数R = 0.48,P值为0.015。正则化协方差矩阵的SCR与Gleason评分的线性拟合发现相关系数R = 0.39,P值为0.058。采用改进正则化协方差矩阵的SCR与Gleason评分的线性拟合发现相关系数R = 0.52,P值为0.007。从协方差矩阵中滤除3个和4个特征向量后的SCR与Gleason评分的线性拟合分别发现相关系数R = 0.50和0.44,P值分别为0.011和0.027。
使用从空间配准的多参数MRI导出的经过滤波和正则化的协方差矩阵得到的z分数和SCR与Gleason评分相关,P值具有高度显著性。